Some people get giddy at the thought of rolling up their sleeves and improving a home for profit, but do they really know the savings of a typical fixer-upper home in their market?

  • The national fixer-upper discount is 7.6 percent from the median priced home, which leaves just $11,000 as a renovation budget to break even.
  • The largest incentive for fixer-upper homes is in San Francisco, where the fixer-upper discount is 9.4 percent, leaving homeowners $54,000 to make renovations.
  • Homebuyers in Phoenix are better off not buying a fixer-upper home, which only saves 0.4 percent, leaving $1,000 for renovations.
Two men installing a window in a fixer upper house

zlikovec / Shutterstock.com

Some people get giddy at the thought of rolling up their sleeves and improving a home for profit, but do they really know the savings of a typical fixer-upper home in their market?

According to a new Zillow Digs analysis, national trends show home listings that require serious improvement might not be financially worth it for homebuyers.

Compared to the market value, fixer-upper homes — which, for this purpose, have keywords like “good bones,” “TLC” and “fixer-upper” in their listing description — list for 7.6 percent less. For the median priced fixer-upper, that’s a savings of $11,000.

While $11,000 is a serious chunk of change, it wouldn’t cover major renovations like a kitchen over-haul or projects that cover a home’s structural integrity. And, naturally, the savings are hugely dependent on a home’s location.

Zillow studied nearly 70,000 listings throughout the nation, comparing their estimated values based on whether the home is considered to be a fixer-upper or a move-in ready home.

San Francisco homebuyers willing to put in some hard work may get the highest value of a home, the report shows. The median fixer-upper will save buyers 9.5 percent, giving them $54,000 in renovation costs to get to the breakeven point. Fixer-upper homes make up 2 percent of the entire stock of housing in San Francisco.

On the other end of the spectrum, residents of Phoenix may stray away from the idea of purchasing a fixer-upper home, which cost just 0.4 percent less than the local market value, according to Zillow data. This leaves homebuyers with just $1,000 for renovations. Of all the listings in Phoenix, just 0.9 percent are fixer-uppers.

Where it’s worth the work

Chicago residents looking to buy a fixer-upper home can get a pretty good discount compared with the market value.

Zillow reports Chicago fixer-upper homes to be 13.8 percent below market value, giving buyers about $19,000 to work with for renovations. Of all listings in Chicago, fixer-uppers comprise 1.7 percent of the pool, the report says.

Baltimore is another good place for fixer-upper buyers, who can find this type of home for 16.6 percent less than the market value. That gives buyers $23,000 to spend on renovations to breakeven.

Cincinnati, Cleveland, Pittsburgh, St. Louis and Philadelphia are also good options for buyers looking to fix up a place, Zillow says.

“Fixer-uppers can be a great deal, and they allow buyers to incorporate their personal style into a home while renovating, but it’s still a good idea to do the math before making the leap,” said Svenja Gudell, Zillow chief economist.

Where buying a move-in-ready home makes sense

In big cities like Los Angeles, New York City, Washington D.C. and Miami-Fort Lauderdale, the discount on a fixer-upper home isn’t really worth the cost and headache of renovating and remodeling, the report shows. These cities have reported fixer-upper discounts of 2.7 percent, 4.4 percent, 5.9 percent and 2.9 percent, respectively.

In both NYC and L.A., residents will end up with about $12,000 in order to breakeven with the market value. D.C. residents can get a bit more, at $15,000.

Miami residents won’t make much off a fixer-upper home, saving just about $4,000.

fixer upper data

Email Kimberly Manning

Show Comments Hide Comments

Comments

Sign up for Inman’s Morning Headlines
What you need to know to start your day with all the latest industry developments
Success!
Thank you for subscribing to Morning Headlines.
Back to top
New sessions have been added to Connect Now Agenda on October 20th! Check out the power-packed lineup. SEE THE AGENDA×