Blandville, U.S.A.: An endless landscape of corporate chains

How our built environment was homogenized

Inman News®

Flickr photo by <a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/markjms/2997827136/" target=blank>mjb84</a>.Flickr photo by mjb84.

The other day I was strolling through a local shopping center when I noticed a colorfully ragtag quartet of young travelers camped out in the little plaza outside a chain coffee store.

They were presumably hitchhiking across the country, their entourage complete with two friendly mutts and a couple of beat-up guitars. The whole bunch was in high spirits, although judging by their looks, they'd been on the road for a long, long time.

At first I was reminded of my own teenage travel adventures, when my friends and I had cheerfully slept on sidewalks or railway station floors, immune to the disapproving frowns of the locals.

But then I began to wonder how similar our experiences really were. The plaza these travelers occupied so happily was ringed by 100 percent corporate chain outlets, from the ubiquitous coffee bar to the familiar purveyor of ersatz tacos, to the giant home-improvement outlet, with its inevitable parade of customers driving off with screen doors tied to their roofs.

It was a place at once utterly familiar and utterly forgettable, without a single feature unique to this particular corner of America. Nowadays, there's nothing unusual about these kinds of ultra-generic locations -- in fact, they're becoming almost inescapable.

Hence, what these kids were experiencing -- the simple exhilaration of travel notwithstanding -- would have been pretty much the same whether they'd been in Portland, Maine; or Portland, Ore.; in Lansing, Mich.; or Laredo, Texas. Here they were, gloriously free and ready to take in the United States, yet for much of the time the places they went all looked the same.

Don't get me wrong. America is a land of incomparable natural contrasts -- of mountain, deserts and prairie, of oceans of water and oceans of wheat. Mother Nature has blessed us with plenty to see and this, one hopes, will never change.

Yet the places where we actually spend most of our time -- the erstwhile charismatic cities, the formerly charming whistle-stop towns, and the increasingly vast stretches of bland, lookalike suburbs in between -- have less and less to distinguish them as the years pass.

Our nation's once culturally distinct landscapes are slowly congealing into a homogenized, study group-induced, corporate marketer's idea of nirvana, in which one business plan conveniently fits all because every crossroads is interchangeable. Only the backlit plastic signs need their logos changed now and then.

History is cyclical, of course, and it may be that the insidious spread of global megabusiness is just a phase that will grow and then wither -- and along with it, the bland, calculated, one-size-fits-all corporatization of America and the rest of the globe. Still, given today's frenetic electronic linkage of everything and everyone -- and the apparent glee with which young people experience it -- we might just as likely be on a one-way trip to Blandville.

As I watched those four scruffy kids in the bloom of youth, strumming on their beat-up guitars, I felt a little sorry for them. They were traveling America, all right, but they were always ending up in the same place.

Contact Arrol Gellner:
E-mail E-mail Letter to the Editor Letter to the Editor
Share with REmessenger

You must login or register to post a comment.

 
Submitted by Elizabeth Bolton on July 20, 2010 - 10:03am.

Super column. "Bland, calculated, one-size-fits-all" and don't forget - ugly. It's a crying shame what's happened to the American landscape in my lifetime - amazing how quickly we ruined it.

I was fortunate in that I grew up in a town that didn't allow fast food restaurants. I think Papa Gino's finally was allowed but they had to use china plates. That was the start though - the two large coffee chains now have dueling shops. For the most part though the downtown survives with interesting and unique shops frequented by locals and tourists.

We can fight back by pushing for better zoning regulations and by shopping and eating at local establishments. We're casting a vote and crafting our future with every dollar we spend.

Liz Bolton
http://centersandsquares.com

 
Submitted by Robin Ervin on July 25, 2010 - 9:25am.

So true....but we clearly have the choice to frequent our own locally owned, independent shops and businesses. I make a point of always utilizing our own locals!

 
Submitted by Judy Orr on July 25, 2010 - 3:40pm.

I hate flying so decided that my trip to the French Riviera was the last time I'd go there. Yet I keep thinking of the beautiful towns we hit and how different shopping and living (and driving) was in this country, and I imagine there are many European areas just like this. They have managed to bring these cities up-to-date but have certainly kept the history and charm.

I fight between visiting more of America vs. going overseas, but there really isn't much of a comparison in our New World here in the USA.

Judy Orr
Classic Realty Group
Orland Park IL Real Estate