Waiting for the real estate fallout
Letter to the Editor
By Inman News, Tuesday, February 10, 2009.Re: 'End of the independent contractor' (Feb. 6)
Dear Editor:
You don't have to be a commercial real estate broker to understand that a retail shopping mall is not in the business of selling goods to the public; it is in the business of attracting and retaining quality retailers. They do so by signing "anchor" retailers and by marketing their mall brand. The higher-quality stores it can attract, the more shoppers it will attract. The more customers it attracts, the higher the likelihood that the mall will have a low vacancy rate and will be paid on time each month.
The mall then makes its money through the collection of rents and by retaining a percentage of sales (in a nutshell). Real estate brokerages are the same; they are not in the business of selling properties to or for the public but, rather, are in the business of hiring and retaining the most productive agents. Some try to do this through low fees, while others do this by creating an excellent brand. Aren't we agents basically "stores" in the mall?
Sears would not sign over its profits to the owners of the mall in exchange for a monthly stipend and a few additional bonuses for volume, but a mediocre teriyaki stand that is making it day-by-day might. In the same way, a broker offering a salary-plus-bonus plan would attract only those who don't have the know-how to be wildly successful. By nature they'd attract only those who aren't capable of making it on their own. If a broker opened up in my town right now and began offering a few thousand dollars per month salary, they'd have agents lined up around the block like a soup line during the Great Depression. The only agents who WOULDN'T be in the line are the successful ones!
Agents need to understand that they are solely responsible for their own success. This is not a job, it is a business. You don't work for your broker -- you partner with them. In fact, I am my broker's customer -- not an employee. The brokers make the space available and hopefully give you a solid brand on which to hang your hat. The rest is up to you.
If you want a salaried job, hop on CareerBuilder.com and start looking. If you want to own a business, go find me one where you can earn six figures with so little investment and overhead, and with such a quick startup time. Instead of worrying about salaries from brokers, focus on being the best agent in your market area. Offer the best property photos and marketing for exposure.
Practice your negotiating skills and get your clients high prices when you're listing, low prices when you're helping them buy. Follow up well, so that your past clients can't help but sing your praises and refer you. Be active in your community so others know who you are. Donate to charity because it's the right thing to do and watch the grace naturally flow over into your business. Be smart in how and where you spend money -- and save, save, save. We will come out of this dark time, but it will happen again. In other words: Take charge of yourself and your business.
I think we need to slow down all of the talk about how pay structure needs to change in dramatic ways. What really needs to happen is that we who are performers have to wait out the nonperformers. Once enough agents have been beat up long enough, they'll simply decide not to get relicensed, and those still standing will make that much more money on the upswing. Frankly, this natural cycle will create an unintended benefit to the general public: Only solid, knowledgeable agents will be standing at the end.
Walk in to any commission-based business and ask the sales staff if they'd rather be on commission or earn a salary. The top half will always say "commission," and the bottom half will always say "salary." In our industry, it would probably be more like 70 percent wanting the salary because, as we all know, a relative few make most of the money.
Of course, once the media begins touting that the industry is beginning to turn around and the sun is out once again, we'll go back to normal. Millions of uneducated people will see real estate as a quick, easy way to make a lot of money and will line back up to get a license.
Hey, I know -- let's make it more difficult and more expensive to obtain a first-year license and put more cost and training requirements on the first couple of renewals! What if we required an associate's degree before real estate classes could be taken? There's a reason everybody's not an attorney or a doctor. I run a real estate practice in much the same way those professionals might run theirs. Our requirements certainly don't need to be as sturdy as theirs, but do we really have to pass out a license to anybody with a breath?
Chad Clement
John L. Scott Real Estate
Puyallup, Wash.
***
What's your opinion? Leave your comments below or send a letter to the editor.
All rights reserved. This content may not be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever, in part or in whole, without written permission of Inman News. Use of this content without permission is a violation of federal copyright law.

You must login or register to post a comment.
Submitted by Joseph Bridges on February 10, 2009 - 6:04am.
YES! This is a great post John and a fantastic way to put it as well.
This brings up a word that many don't want to be in real estate and that is "accountable". We are all accountable in real estate to produce what we need each and every day.
With the opportunties in real estate to determine your own salary come the risks as well but there are risks in everything if you look at what is happeneing in the economy.
You must take responsibilty for "your business" as this post states and if you don't it probably isn't the business for you.
Visit the blog at: http://www.InternetRealEstateSuccess.com
Real Estate Resources at: http://www.OnlineRealEstateSuccess.com
Submitted by Ross Milroy on February 10, 2009 - 7:49am.
Chad,
Thank you for being open and putting out your thoughts on the lack of accountability in real estate. The barriers to entry in this business need to be raised much higher. In Florida, for example, you do not need to be a resident nor a citizen to obtain a real estate license. All you need to apply is a valid Florida drivers license.
Ross Milroy
Miami Angel Properties, LLC
http://www.miamiangelproperties.com
Visit our Inside South Beach Real Estate Journal
Submitted by Austin Smith on February 10, 2009 - 7:53am.
Nice post Chad. I never thought of the broker/agent relationship in this way, but you are very correct.
Could we go so far as to blame part of this recession on the brokers themselves? Shoddy hiring/screening practices yields a surplus of shoddy agents; agents who will then be skimmed off the top and kicked to the curb like so much pond scum.
I would agree with you that renewal fees and bolstered requirements for new agents are a path worth exploring. If we make real estate more of an elitist group, not only will the average quality-of-agent go up, but I would assume it would loosen up the industry some. Issues like the nation-wide MLS might be resolved more swiftly if there are less voices clamoring to be heard.
Submitted by Patti Barrett on February 10, 2009 - 8:13am.
John! Most excellent. In Colorado, both our MLS system and our State have simply upped their rates for renewal and initial license fees. It is surprising how many people have not gotten their brand spanking new real estate license. We went from 25+ new license entries to our MLS to approximately 10 a month because of the fees. Many, in this downturn have left the business... Countless new agents tell me they got " into the business" because it appeared to be "easy" money. I laugh! I know it is not nice to laugh, but after 20 years+ in the business, working on my referral system, learning to market, to print, to negotiate, to use new technology, to anticipate objections and questions, to learn website technology and.....well, you know! I built my business, they are responsible for building theirs. These new "easy"agents begin to find out that the business is in fact NOT easy!
I doubt there is any broker with funds enough to pay real estate salaries plus a bonus for sales. That would break even the largest companies. Tax,rent,unemployment insurance and on and on....insanity. This particular time, I see as a "weed out", only the hearty and best will survive. Whew, Finally. However, when the business returns, and it will, the "easy money" crowd will ride again on the coat tails of those who practice Real Estate as a profession. We are still overcoming the Used Car Salesman trauma because of the easy group, and that too will return.
Personally, you put the facts in place! Thank you! Patti Barrett
Submitted by Lola Audu on February 10, 2009 - 4:09pm.
A highly productive real estate agent would likely find that a salary is luxury that they couldn't afford!
Several years ago, I worked for a company which launched a modified fee structure to provide its agents with 'flexibility' in their monthly payments. When I did the math, it was obvious that it would have cost me way to much cash to be 'liberated.'
As the number of transactions per agent drops, (in our area to approx 6-7) per year one wonders if providing a salary above minimum wage would be an astutue financial move for brokers who consider this route.
Lola Audu, CRS, GRI e-Pro
Audu Real Estate
Grand Rapids, Michigan
www.auduhomes.com
Submitted by Bill Fooks on February 10, 2009 - 4:26pm.
Bill Fooks
TFT realty Marketing Service
Warwick, RI http://www.fooksteam.com
Great Post. I hope some companies give them a choice. Then when I go up against them in the field, I feel very confident who will win the signature.
Game on and lets go! I will stay on the commission trail and make my presentation accordingly.