Inman

Tell inspector about mold or stay quiet?

Dear Barry,

We’re about to buy a six-year-old home that originally had a mold problem. Fortunately, the builder removed all of the affected materials from the building. If we buy this home, are we required to disclose the initial mold issue to our home inspector, or should we wait to see if he notices any evidence of mold? –Jack

Dear Jack,

What possible advantage could there be in withholding information that would assist your home inspector in evaluating the property you are buying? The inspector is your hired consultant, there for your exclusive benefit and to provide you with essential decision-making data. Any information or other assistance you can provide toward full evaluation of the property is to your advantage. If the property has a history of mold, let your inspector know about it. That way, pertinent moisture conditions and related defects can be carefully considered and evaluated during the inspection.

Testing your inspector, rather than lending your trust and assistance, can have costly consequences. Here’s a true story that illustrates the point: The buyers of a home had been told the property was located within a flood plain, but they never mentioned this to their home inspector. The inspector observed no evidence of potential flooding and therefore made no disclosure of it in his report. The buyers therefore dismissed the issue of possible flooding and proceeded with the purchase. After the close of escrow, the first heavy rains caused ground water to flood the interior of their home. They blamed the home inspector for this "surprise" and filed a lawsuit for nondisclosure, even though they had withheld prior knowledge of flood potential on the day of the inspection.

If you alert your home inspector to the history of mold infection, then potential moisture sources such as plumbing leaks, roof leaks and ground drainage problems can be given particular attention during the inspection. By withholding that disclosure, there is greater likelihood that a significant issue could be missed.

Be aware also that home inspectors do not make determinations regarding the presence of mold. Since the property has a mold history, you would be prudent to hire a mold expert to affirm that there is no residual mold infection in the building.

Dear Barry,

We’re thinking about adding a room to our house, and we’ve already done some remodeling. Is there any way to find out the current value of our house and the added value if we were to proceed with the addition? We are not looking to sell any time soon, but knowing the added value of an extra room would help us to make this decision. –Sheri

Dear Sheri,

The best way to determine market value is to hire an accredited real estate appraiser. A qualified appraiser can provide a comparison of current value with the projected value after the remodeling work and the addition are completed, based on comparisons with similar properties in the area. A less expensive approach would be to contact a real estate broker for a market analysis of your home. However, since you don’t plan to sell your home, that could be an unfair waste of the broker’s time. If you call a broker, be sure to disclose that you are not planning to sell.

To write to Barry Stone, please visit him on the Web at www.housedetective.com.

***

What’s your opinion? Leave your comments below or send a letter to the editor. To contact the writer, click the byline at the top of the story.