Walkaway's unfortunate consequence

Q: My parents signed the title of their home over to me some years ago, with a small mortgage. The place is in a high-crime area, and has depreciated significantly over the last few years. No one in our family wanted to live there, and I didn't want to deal with tenants, even though my Realtor told me that with Section 8 tenants, I would have $700 in positive cash flow every month. (There is rent control in my area, and tenants can be a real hassle.)

Anyhow, I put the place on the market several times over the last few years, but it never sold. Finally, I stopped making the payments and decided to walk away from it. At the same time, though, I let my Realtor put it back on the market on the off chance (it would sell).

She got a full-price offer at a price that would pay the mortgage off in full, plus some, even after commissions! By the time we got the offer, though, a trustee sale had already been scheduled. My Realtor faxed the offer multiple times to the bank, but they claimed they didn't get it and they just went ahead and foreclosed on it. What should I have done differently here?

A: There's a long answer, and there's a short answer. I think you're looking to see how you could have handled the offer process differently, or how you might have been able to get the bank to stop the foreclosure process pending your sale of the home. That's the short answer, and we'll go there momentarily.

But first things first: There were lots of places you might have made different decisions in order to end up in a different place. I'll avoid preaching, because I've seen how these sequences of events can unfold, and I know the pressure, stress and conflicting information that can be involved. But you could certainly have rented the place out. I'm not a big fan of unwilling folks bringing tenants into their lives -- especially in rent- or eviction-controlled jurisdictions and situations (like Section 8). However, it does seems that the cumulative financial upside of (a) keeping the property, (b) preserving the credit of whomever holds the mortgage on the property (one of your parents?) and c) getting the rental income might have been worth the potential for hassle.

What I hear you saying, though, is that you really didn't want to keep the property. It sounds like the neighborhood and housing values had deteriorated sufficiently to render the property more of a burden than a blessing to you. Did you consider giving it back to your parents? They might have been more willing to put the effort into renting it for passive income or aggressively marketing it for sale before the foreclosure process was even initiated.

But alas, that was not to be. So, assuming all else went as it did -- when you got the final, full-price offer, was there anything you could have done differently to end up with a positive net sale, rather than losing the place to foreclosure? It sounds like you needed to personally be on the phone for as long as it took to get your offer in the hands of someone with the authority to stop the sale. ...CONTINUED

All rights reserved. This article may not be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever, in part or in whole, without written permission of Inman News. Use of this article without permission is a violation of federal copyright law.