Common ways sellers fudge their listings

Don't believe everything you read on for-sale flier

Inman News®

Some people just don't get it. If you advertise a house as having a San Francisco Bay view, buyers will expect to walk into a public room like the living room and see the bay. They won't be satisfied with a peek of the bay from the master bathroom.

Exaggerating in advertising not only leads to disappointment, it can have legal consequences. For example, sellers have been sued over misrepresenting square footage.

Usually, sellers think their house or land is bigger than it is. They hope that by advertising the property as bigger, they will sell for a higher price. But, if the sellers are later sued when the buyers discover that the property is quite a bit smaller, the sellers could end up paying out far more than the profit they received from the sale.

Most buyers would be pleased to know that their home had been built by a renowned architect. It's fine to advertise that fact, if you have evidence to confirm that the information is accurate. Sometimes sellers or their agents think a house looks like it was designed by a certain architect so they advertise this as fact.

A number of years ago, a couple bought a home that was advertised as designed by Julia Morgan, whose most famous work was "La Casa Grande," William Randolph Hearst's home at San Simeon, Calif.

The buyers discovered just before closing that the house had not been designed by Julia Morgan. They had already sold their home and had nowhere to go, so they went through with the transaction. Even though the buyers found out about the deceptive advertising before the sale closed, they were able to successfully sue the sellers and their agent for false advertising.

Misleading advertising can occur regarding the numbers of bedrooms and bathrooms. Some sellers would rather advertise more than they should. But, if the fourth bedroom is a tiny sunroom with an add-on closet, buyers who need four full-sized bedrooms are going to be turned off when they realize that the house has only three rooms that can be used as full-time bedrooms.

HOUSE HUNTING TIP: From a purely marketing standpoint, it's usually better to undersell than oversell. Buyers who have expectations about your house based on the advertising will not buy your house once they realize it doesn't have what they want or need. Buyers who want a view want to be able to sit in a room and enjoy it. They won't be satisfied with a view you can see only if you hang over the side of a deck.

Buyers will be in a much more favorable mood to buy your home if they find that it actually has more than they were expecting. With this in mind, it would be better to advertise the four-bedroom home mentioned above as a three-plus-bedroom home. This way the buyers are expecting only three proper bedrooms. They may be delighted to find that there is an extra room that can be used as a home office, nursery, den or occasional guest room.

Disclosure laws vary from state to state. But, it makes good sense to be straightforward in your real estate dealings, especially when it comes to how you advertise your home to the public.

THE CLOSING: Buyers should make sure they do careful due diligence investigations to confirm information that's disclosed to them in an ad, or elsewhere, that would make a substantial difference to them, like whether an additional bedroom was added with permit, or whether the architect is who the seller says it is.

Dian Hymer is a nationally syndicated real estate columnist and author of "House Hunting, The Take-Along Workbook for Home Buyers" and "Starting Out, The Complete Home Buyer's Guide," Chronicle Books.

***

What's your opinion? Leave your comments below or send a letter to the editor. To contact the writer, click the byline at the top of the story.

Share with REmessenger

You must login or register to post a comment.

 
Submitted by Emmanuel Scanlan on September 22, 2008 - 4:02am.

This is a very interesting article and leads to one main question. Where is the Real Estate Agent when the description of the home is created? What you describe sounds a little more than just fudging a listing!

It is understandable that an RE Agent can not know exactly everything about a home that is generally placed in a listing description. However, it appears to me you are inferring that RE Agents are very creative (to be gentle with wording) when they write these listing descriptions?

PS Inspection & Property Services LLC
www.psinspection.com

Knowledge is power, but sharing knowledge brings peace!!

 
Submitted by Michael Daly on September 22, 2008 - 4:45am.

Diane,
I agree with Emmanuel. It is very diplomatic of you to report on how the "sellers" fudge listing info. My experience is that the agent is often a partner, if not the originator, in the 'exaggerations' such as waterfront, waterview, last of it's kind, square footage, number of bedrooms and value. It's one of the reasons that real estate agents are so low on the list of trusted professionals AND a big factor in why I have decided to become an exclusive buyers broker - see: http://thehamptons.wordpress.com/2008/09/16/hamptons-real-estate-buyers-...

In the extremely competitive listings market of the last 6-7 years, agents have bid up the offering prices of homes in order to secure the listing - after all, listings WERE guaranteed income from 2000 - 2005. I'm sure those days will come again, but in the meantime, consumers have become better educated and more aware and exaggerated listings won't even get a second look.

The new term in town: Moral Hazard

Michael Daly
The Hamptons Real Estate Blog

 
Submitted by Wenceslao Fernandez Jr, BS, Realtor, CDPE on September 24, 2008 - 6:53pm.

I really don't see where the remarks about where the Realtor was in this article come to light. It seems to me Dian is talking to sellers and not to Realtors.

The point is well taken though, and both sellers and Realtors must be checking each other to avoid liability and to ensure a property is underpromised and overdelivered so to speak.

If a seller tells me that the property is built or designed by "x" famous architect, before advertising that we, as professionals, must request for proof or verification and ask the sellers to keep that information handy and ready to pass on to the buyers.

Sellers in general should similarly ensure their claims are supported and that if they hire a Realtor, that they are in no way misrepresenting the property (albeit for being overly zelous).

www.MiamiRealEstateKing.com
Certified Distressed Property Expert
Miami-Dade County, Florida.