Bigger. Better. Bolder. Inman Connect is heading to San Diego. Join thousands of real estate pros, connect with the Inman Community, and gain insights from hundreds of leading minds shaping the industry. If you’re ready to grow your business and invest in yourself, this is where you need to be. Go BIG in San Diego!
If you’ve been paying even the slightest attention to the multifamily market, you’ve probably sensed that something major is shifting beneath the surface. The days of easy deals and sky-high valuations are over. Cap rates are rising, transactions have slowed dramatically and a massive wave of bridge loan maturities is forcing property owners into difficult decisions.
TAKE THE INMAN INTEL SURVEY FOR MAY
Institutional capital — the same institutional money that was aggressively acquiring multifamily assets just two years ago — is now playing a completely different game, sitting on the sidelines or circling distressed opportunities like sharks smelling blood in the water.
But what’s actually causing this seismic shift? More importantly, how does this impact the broader real estate landscape, especially for residential agents? If you think what’s happening in multifamily doesn’t affect you, think again.
These forces don’t just shape investment markets — they influence everything from single-family home prices to rental demand, investor behavior and even the psychology of homebuyers. If you’re not following the money and understanding these trends, you’re operating at a serious disadvantage.
What’s happening right now in the multifamily space isn’t just a correction — it’s a full-scale restructuring of the real estate economy, and those who see the patterns early will be in the best position to thrive.
The tectonic shift in multifamily
To fully grasp the magnitude of what’s happening in the multifamily sector today, we have to step back and understand the extraordinary economic and financial forces that shaped the last few years. This isn’t just a market correction — it’s a reckoning, a fundamental restructuring of how capital flows through commercial real estate. And those who don’t understand the past few years’ financial engineering won’t be prepared for what’s coming next.
From 2020 through 2022, we witnessed one of the most aggressive real estate booms in modern history. The combination of record-low interest rates, unprecedented government stimulus, and a global flight to hard assets created the perfect storm for multifamily investment.
Institutional capital flooded into the sector, syndicators were raising money at breakneck speed, and even first-time investors were piling in, armed with cheap debt and the belief that appreciation was all but guaranteed.
The fuel behind this boom? Ultra-low borrowing costs and an era of financial optimism that made deals look artificially good on paper. Investors and developers were underwriting deals at razor-thin margins, assuming that rents would continue to rise indefinitely, cap rates would remain low and permanent financing would always be available to bail them out of short-term debt structures.
At the height of this frenzy, we saw historically low cap rates — sometimes dipping below 4 percent — with investors pricing in near-zero risk as they aggressively acquired properties. Institutional buyers, private equity firms and syndicators alike structured deals that only made sense if rents climbed significantly year after year and if exit opportunities remained favorable.
Debt was so cheap and readily available that risk management became an afterthought for many players. The strategy was simple: Buy at a premium, push rents as fast as possible and refinance into long-term debt before the music stopped.
Then, the music stopped.
By mid-2023, the financial landscape had undergone a dramatic shift. The Federal Reserve’s aggressive rate hikes sent borrowing costs soaring, with the 10-year Treasury yield surpassing 4 percent — a key benchmark for commercial real estate financing. Suddenly, that once-affordable financing wasn’t just more expensive — it was, in some cases, two to three times the original cost of capital.
That’s where the real pain began.
A vast portion of the multifamily market had been built on bridge loans — short-term, interest-only financing designed to hold properties temporarily. At the same time, investors executed value-add strategies or refinanced into long-term debt.
Those bridge loans, which often had initial rates in the 3 percent to 4 percent range, are now coming due. However, with permanent financing rates now in the 7 percent to 8 percent range (or even higher for less-than-pristine assets), many investors are finding themselves underwater, unable to refinance at terms that make sense.
The result?
A flood of distressed sales, capital calls and even outright foreclosures. Some investors are trying to raise new equity just to survive, but many deals are simply unsalvageable. The underwriting assumptions from just two years ago no longer hold.
Rent growth has slowed, operational expenses have increased due to inflation, and net operating income (NOI) projections have fallen short. In many cases, these properties are worth significantly less than what they were purchased for, leaving investors with few options beyond selling at a loss or handing the keys back to lenders.
But here’s the thing: The problem isn’t just higher interest rates. It’s the systemic over-leverage that was built into the market during the boom. Many operators justified aggressive purchase prices with unrealistic assumptions — assuming cap rates would never rise, assuming rents would climb forever, and assuming they could always refinance their way out of trouble.
Those assumptions have now unraveled.
What we’re witnessing is a forced deleveraging cycle, one that will reshape the multifamily landscape for years to come. And for those who truly understand what’s happening, this is where the biggest opportunities — and the biggest risks — are unfolding.
Where the smart money is moving next
The smartest players in the game aren’t sitting on the sidelines — they’re adjusting their sails while others are caught in the storm. In real estate, just like in a volatile stock market, fortunes aren’t made by following the herd when times are good; they’re made by those who position themselves ahead of the next big move.
Institutional buyers who were priced out in the frenzied bidding wars of 2021 and 2022 are now returning to the table, but this time, they hold the upper hand. They’re armed with cash, waiting patiently to acquire distressed assets at 20 percent to 30 percent discounts from peak pricing.
It’s a classic case of Warren Buffett’s philosophy at work: Be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful. Currently, many overleveraged owners are feeling the squeeze, while those who kept their powder dry are stepping in to pick up the pieces.
However, while institutional players have the advantage of deep war chests, some of the most strategic operators are making their moves not just by writing big checks, but by structuring deals creatively. They’re using preferred equity to inject fresh capital into struggling assets, negotiating assumable debt transactions to lock in older, lower-rate financing and structuring seller carrybacks that keep deals alive in an environment where traditional financing is difficult.
Think of it as a game of financial chess — those who understand how to use these advanced strategies aren’t just surviving, they’re thriving.
The wildcard: Developers
If the market were a poker game, developers would be the players holding a risky hand, waiting to see how the next few rounds play out. The cost of capital has skyrocketed, labor shortages continue to plague construction timelines, and many projects that made sense in 2021 now look questionable under today’s financing terms. Across the country, new construction has slowed dramatically because higher debt costs have rendered pro formas that once looked profitable on paper unprofitable.
And yet, the most seasoned developers aren’t walking away from the table — they’re just playing differently. Instead of relying on conventional financing, they’re partnering with capital sources that have a long-term vision and understand that real estate is a marathon, not a sprint. In many ways, the current moment in development is akin to a gold rush, where only those with the right equipment and a deep understanding of the terrain will strike it rich.
One of the key factors separating winners from losers is location. While national trends indicate a slowdown in development, select markets still exhibit demand-supply imbalances that render specific projects viable. Some regions continue to experience in-migration trends that bolster demand for housing, while others face such severe undersupply that even higher borrowing costs can’t dampen long-term returns (Yardi Matrix, January 2024).
In short, the game is changing, and those who adapt are setting themselves up for incredible opportunities in the next cycle. This isn’t just about weathering the storm — it’s about emerging from it stronger, more prepared, and ready to capitalize when the tide turns.
Why residential agents need to pay attention
You might be thinking, I sell homes, not apartments. Why does this matter?
Here’s why: The same financial currents pulling multifamily investors under are shaping the behavior of buyers and sellers in your market right now, whether they realize it or not. Residential agents who understand these larger forces won’t just survive the shifting market — they’ll thrive in it.
1. Interest rates are pushing renters back toward buying
For the last two years, rising mortgage rates kept many would-be buyers on the sidelines, forcing them into the rental market. But as multifamily landlords struggle with higher debt costs, they’re passing those expenses on to tenants. Single-family rents are rising, and in many markets, it’s becoming cheaper to buy than to rent again.
What this means for you: Agents should actively target long-term renters who were previously hesitant to buy but may now find ownership the better financial move. This is the moment to educate them with rent vs. buy comparisons that take current rent inflation into account.
Action step: Market to high-end renters — especially those in newly built apartment complexes — who may be seeing renewal rates jump by 10 percent or more. These are prime candidates for homeownership, especially with down payment assistance or creative financing options.
2. Investment buyers are pivoting from multifamily to single-family rentals (SFRs)
Many of the same investors who were flipping apartment buildings two years ago are now shifting their attention to single-family rental portfolios. They’re looking for homes in strong rental markets, and they’re engaging in bulk deals to deploy capital that’s no longer viable in multifamily properties.
What this means for you: If you’re only considering individual homebuyers, you’re missing out on an entire subset of investors who are actively seeking rent-ready single-family homes.
Action step: Position yourself as the agent who understands the shift. Study which areas in your market are attracting institutional and mid-sized investors. Learn how to package deals for bulk buyers — even small landlords are now looking to acquire multiple homes instead of just one.
3. A wave of motivated sellers is coming, and it’s not just commercial owners
We know that over-leveraged apartment owners are struggling, but the same issue is also affecting single-family landlords who purchased at the peak. Some of these owners took on risky loans, overpaid for properties or relied on Airbnb income that hasn’t panned out. Now, they need out.
What this means for you: Motivated sellers create off-market opportunities for both investors and end-user buyers. The agent who can identify and bring these deals together will be the one to dominate.
Action step: Use data tools to identify distressed landlords. Look for properties that were purchased in 2021-22 with adjustable-rate financing or Airbnb properties with declining occupancy rates. Cold outreach to these owners could unlock hidden listing inventory.
4. Luxury and second-home buyers are moving capital out of multifamily
High-net-worth buyers who previously allocated capital toward multifamily syndications are rethinking their portfolios. They’re still investing in real estate, but many are diverting funds into luxury primary homes, second homes and short-term rental properties instead.
What this means for you: The buyers who once chased 10 percent multifamily returns are now looking for safer, tangible assets and a luxury home in a prime location fits the bill.
Action step: Re-engage past clients who were hesitant about luxury real estate. Many are sitting on cash that was initially earmarked for investment properties. Show them why buying in select high-end markets now could be a strong move.
5. The agents who see this first will win big
The domino effect of multifamily distress is creating once-in-a-decade opportunities in the residential space. Buyers who thought they were locked out are re-entering, investors are redirecting capital and distressed sellers are surfacing.
The question is: Will you be the agent who understands the shift and gets ahead of it? Or the one playing catch-up?
What comes next
The next 12 to 18 months won’t just be a sorting-out period — they’ll be a full-blown shake-the-tree-and-see-who-hangs-on kind of moment in real estate.
Think of it like musical chairs. The music played nonstop from 2020 to 2022, and everyone was sprinting to grab as many chairs (deals) as possible. But now? The music has slowed, some chairs have vanished, and suddenly, a bunch of investors and operators are realizing they don’t have a place to sit. Those who were overleveraged, ran on wishful thinking, or bet their entire strategy on perpetual price appreciation? They’re in trouble. And the ones who understand how to navigate this new reality — with creative deal structuring, sharp asset management and smart capital positioning — are about to thrive like never before.
Residential agents, your world is changing, too, whether you like it or not
Let’s get one thing straight: if you’re a residential agent and you’re not paying attention to what’s happening in multifamily, you’re flying blind into the biggest shift in real estate we’ve seen in over a decade.
Why? Because every macro move in commercial real estate has a direct, street-level impact on your market. Investors are repositioning, homeowners are reevaluating, and even first-time buyers are being influenced by these larger forces. The agents who get this will be the ones who grab market share while everyone else is still trying to figure out why their usual playbook isn’t working.
I’ve seen this movie before. And let me tell you — the people who win big in this business are the ones who understand the entire real estate landscape, not just their little corner of it. That’s exactly how my national sales organization closed roughly $2 billion in aggregated sales last year — by seeing the trends before they hit the headlines, by making moves while others were hesitating, and by positioning our agents and investors to capitalize on what’s next.
The big money in real estate is made in the transitions
Let’s talk real estate cycles for a second, because this is where the magic happens. Everyone loves to talk about how much money was made in 2021-22 when everything was booming. But here’s the truth: the biggest fortunes in real estate aren’t made when everyone is winning. They’re made in the transitions — when the market shifts and the old playbook stops working.
That’s where we are right now.
The agents who wake up to this reality first are going to absolutely dominate the next decade. The ones who keep doing what worked three years ago, hoping for different results? They’re going to get steamrolled by the competition.
This is your wake-up call. Are you ready to see the whole board?
The future belongs to the agents who think bigger, move faster and aren’t afraid to adapt. You don’t have to become a commercial broker. You don’t have to start underwriting apartment complexes. However, if you want to stay ahead, grow your business and be the agent investors and high-net-worth clients turn to, you must understand how these shifts impact your market and start adjusting your strategy.
Because the agents see where the market is going before the rest of the industry reacts? They’re the ones who win big.
So the only real question left is: Are you one of them?
