Most state license lookups give consumers an incomplete or misleading picture of disciplinary actions against real estate agents, according to a new report from the Consumer Policy Center (CPC). The Washington, D.C.-based independent think tank, which launched in early 2025, has a mission to “undertake research and commentary to advance the consumer interest.”
The CPC report, released Tuesday and titled “Evaluating State Disclosure of Disciplinary Actions Against Real Estate Agents,” reviewed official real estate license search portals in all 50 U.S. states. It rated just two — Illinois and Arizona — as providing “good” access to disciplinary records.
“State regulators need no additional authority to increase consumer access to important information about agents they may employ,” Wendy Gilch, a CPC fellow and the report’s author, said in a release. “Regulators need only a stronger commitment to their statutory obligation to protect home buyers and sellers.”
How state lookups fall short
From September 2026 through November 2026, a CPC researcher examined each state’s official real estate license search portal — or license lookup — assessing whether disciplinary actions were easy to find and to understand.
Here’s how the CPC scored states on their reporting of disciplinary actions: Being easy to find is worth the most (up to 4 points), followed by plain-language explanation (up to 3) and work history (worth 1 point). Illinois maxed out the two heaviest categories. Arizona got the explanation and work-history points but only partial credit for findability.
States had to score over 5 to be considered “good.”
The report rated 21 states as needing improvement (with scores of 3 to 5 points) and 24 as providing poor access (with scores of 0, 1 or 2 points). The 16 states that scored zero are Arkansas, Georgia, Hawaii, Maryland, Mississippi, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Utah and West Virginia.
Only three states (Illinois, Delaware and Idaho) flagged a disciplinary action in the first summary or search result the consumer sees. Only Illinois both flags the action and explains it in plain language, according to the report.
Three states (Kentucky, Washington and Wyoming) could not be rated.
Across most states, the report found disciplinary actions buried, mislabeled, left off the lookup or never made public. Among the most egregious issues were agents charged with serious crimes that can remain licensed and show a clean record for months or years. The report also pointed out rare instances when an agent makes the news and the record may disappear from the lookup for a time and reappear later.
Top rated states, though none are perfect
Illinois (scoring 7 out of 8 points) was the only state that did the two most important things together. It flags a disciplinary action right on the licensee’s summary — the first thing a consumer sees — and it explains in plain language what happened. Illinois lost one point because its lookup doesn’t show an agent’s past brokerages.
Arizona (scoring 6 out of 8 points) won on explanation and work history. It describes actions in plain language and is one of only two states, with California, that lists the brokerages an agent has worked for. Its weakness is visibility: There’s no flag up front, so a consumer has to click into the profile and scroll to find the action. (California also shows work history, but it doesn’t explain actions in plain language, so it scored 4, or “needs improvement”.)
AI didn’t fill the gap
The CPC tested whether an AI tool could answer a basic question consumers might ask: “Has this agent been disciplined by the state?” The report researcher gave Claude Opus 5.5 each agent’s name, license number and state — using the same licensees from the lookup review — in all 47 rated states. “The AI could search the web to answer, a feature free accounts also have, but we did not use paid tools that let AI open websites and search state license lookups on our behalf,” the report explained.
In 34 of the 47 states, the AI tool found no record of any action. The report warns that a consumer could easily take that silence as a clean record. Misses included Illinois and Arizona, the two states rated “good.” In the 13 states where Claude did find something, the information came from commission meeting minutes, PDFs of signed orders and discipline newsletters — almost never from a page about the agent.
How to fix the problems — according to the CPC
The CPC’s nine recommendations start with the lookup itself. Commissions should flag any disciplinary action in search results and at the top of a licensee’s record, in a caution color such as red or amber, and label it “Disciplinary Actions” instead of terms like “Orders” or “Case History.” Each action should come with a plain-language summary of what the licensee did, why the commission acted and what the penalty was, with the legal documents available behind it, the report says. Records should stay public after a license expires or is revoked, after the licensee completes the terms of discipline and when the licensee is in the news.
Lookups should also list the brokerages an agent has worked for, with dates.
The report also asks commissions to disclose educational and warning letters issued after a violation, and note them on the licensee’s record. Licensees should be required to report within 30 days any state or federal housing or consumer protection action against them, including HUD and FHA fraud, fair housing violations, civil settlements and pretrial diversion, CPC says.
The CPC recommends that every state enroll licensees in the FBI’s fingerprint-based Rap Back monitoring and impose interim suspensions while serious felony charges are resolved, whether or not the charges relate to a transaction.
Also, the report says commissions should publish each action on a public page that search engines can read, labeled with the licensee’s name and license number, so a consumer who asks an AI tool gets the same answer as one who checks the lookup directly.
And finally, the report recommends that states commit to reporting all public discipline to a shared system, and that the Association of Real Estate License Law Officials (ARELLO) and its members open a consumer version of ARELLO’s database.
“Some fixes work best when states act together,” the report says. “Many agents along state borders hold licenses in more than one state, but each state’s record stands alone, and a consumer has no single place to see the full picture.
“The pieces of a solution already exist,” the report explains. “ARELLO, the association of real estate regulators, maintains a national disciplinary database for its members, and the mortgage industry’s NMLS Consumer Access shows that one free, public search across every state is possible. States should commit to reporting all public discipline to a shared system, and ARELLO and its members should open a consumer version: one search that shows every state where an agent is licensed and any public action taken in each.”
Overall, “consumers spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on a purchase should be given information about serious state or federal charges against agents on whom they depend,” Gilch said in the press release. “Consumers should have the ability to determine whether the information will affect their choice of agent.”
Note: Follow-up CPC reports will examine how hard it is for consumers to find and file a complaint.