Compass just filed 15 new federal antitrust lawsuits against multiple listing services in eight states. Fifteen. In one day.
Apparently, the future of residential real estate is going to be decided in federal courtrooms rather than living rooms.
Compass will tell you it asked first, and that some of these MLSs sued before it did. But when the answer to “no” is 15 complaints, the goal isn’t a better rule. It’s a different marketplace.
Changing the rules from inside the trade organizations would be slower and less dramatic. It would also be cheaper, and it might actually benefit the people we’re all supposed to represent.
Compass-MLS battles: The real fight is over inventory
But this war isn’t really about the MLS. It is about data containment.
Compass spent years and extraordinary sums building a technology platform intended to give it a competitive advantage. But technology is advancing so quickly that yesterday’s proprietary innovation is tomorrow’s commodity. The competitive advantage that platform was supposed to deliver may be eroding faster than anticipated.
So what’s left to control? The inventory.
Keep the listings close. Control their distribution. Build a proprietary marketplace. Call it innovation, or disruption.
I work day to day with the former president of William B. May Brooklyn, who used to keep the keys to every listing in the neighborhood in his office. First come, first served. Not an exclusive kind of market.
Compass and Anywhere are playing a very expensive game of keep-away.
Last week, Compass formalized a policy requiring its agents to share listing information with outside brokers upon request, private listings included, unless the seller directs otherwise in writing. Fine. Compass will also remind you that outside agents can view its private exclusives in a Compass office and search its Coming Soon listings on its website.
That adds another step to a busy agent’s workflow and takes us back to the 1980s in terms of access. It is not progress. It is data lockdown, peppered after more than two years with legal advice, in service of one goal: making Compass America’s MLS, or the world’s.
No one can be the world’s MLS. And boy oh boy, as an antitrust lawyer, I would hate to see the legal fees Anywhere and Compass will pay if the DOJ gets back to work in 2028.
Needless to say, a book in someone else’s office and a search bar on a competitor’s site are not comprehensive, searchable access to inventory in the system we all share. You cannot ask about a listing you don’t know exists.
What does cooperation mean now?
Here’s what I find most difficult to reconcile: Real estate agents and brokerages participate in cooperative listing systems precisely because cooperation makes markets work.
In New York, the REBNY Residential Listing Service exists to facilitate the sharing of exclusive listings among participating firms. Is it perfect? Nothing is. But it is fixable; most things are. Fixing it is not the mission here.
If listings can be marketed within one company’s network without being made available through that shared system, what exactly does cooperation mean anymore?
Agents don’t need a courtroom to ask that question.
What would happen if the agents who participate in cooperative listing systems told their own firms and their own listing services, together, that they will not accept a structure in which they share everything and cannot see all the inventory being marketed elsewhere?
What if they said plainly that restricted access disadvantages their clients and their businesses? Their managers would tell them that they are giving away money by diluting their access to inventory.
But when an agent is entrenched in an ecosystem of tech that includes a CRM, listings portal, marketing and apps all combined — it’s really harder to climb out. And the market is hard right now with 7 percent-plus interest rates, macro-uncertainty, a war that is costing the U.S. up to $200 million a day, and a saturated entry pool of agents who watch people on real estate reality TV shows and want in on the action, despite not knowing the market or having experience
Also: What about the agents at the legacy Anywhere brands, now part of the Compass empire? How much money is being spent on litigation, and how much of that capital could otherwise support the agents actually doing the business? What is happening to their marketing budgets and commission splits?
Where independents win
Meanwhile, the actual business of brokerage is remarkably simple: You help people buy and sell homes.
Sometimes your client is a developer answering to a lender. Sometimes it’s a family selling the home where they raised their children. Sometimes it’s a first-time buyer making the biggest financial commitment of their life.
Every transaction has stakes. Every transaction has emotion. Your job as agents is to understand those stakes and deliver exceptional service. Not to use someone’s home as a pawn in a corporate data strategy. And this is where independent brokerages have an extraordinary opportunity.
We don’t have to win a national war over who controls the information. We have to continue to win the trust of the people in our communities. We already know our neighborhoods, understand our clients, develop great agents and actually sell real estate.
No algorithm replaces that relationship. No proprietary database creates it.
Technology will continue to make yesterday’s competitive advantages less exclusive, whether the industry giants like it or not.
The independents will win where real estate has always been won: locally, one client and one transaction at a time. And while they’re busy litigating the future of brokerage, we’ll be out there building it.
Watch us. Come by for a coffee.
The views and opinions expressed here are those of the contributor and separate from the Inman newsroom.
Maggie Ross currently serves as the Senior Managing Director of Brown Harris Stevens Brooklyn. Get connected on LinkedIn.