There are some hidden “money parts” of real estate purchase offers that aren’t discussed much, and this week we’re looking at earnest money deposits (EMDs). Earnest money feels different for buyers because it’s immediate — one minute it’s in your account and the next it’s not.
We need to speak up about EMDs when we first qualify our buyers because if our buyer can’t come up with the deposit money within three business days of contract acceptance, the seller can send the buyer a notice to perform and then cancel the agreement (at least in California) for failing to perform.
Earnest money deposits
Earnest money is the buyer committing their own cash as a deposit. The deposit proves to the seller that the buyer will act in good faith and move forward with the purchase. EMDs are held in escrow accounts until closing and then get credited back towards the buyer’s down payment.
Most of the country runs 1-3 percent of the purchase price, and in California the number is customary rather than fixed, which means it was always negotiable — where I am in San Francisco, it’s 3 percent.
Because it’s so real, buyers seem to have a lot more questions about losing it.
Risk and rule
The rules are short and mostly about timing. Under the C.A.R. purchase agreement, the initial deposit is due within three business days after acceptance — meaning the buyer and seller have ratified the agreement. California’s regulations then require the money to sit in an escrow or broker’s trust account.
There is some risk involved. A buyer who cancels with a contingency in place gets the deposit back. A buyer who cancels without contingencies in place may lose their deposit.
Question: What happens to my EMD when the deal closes?
Answer: When the deal closes, your earnest money deposit is credited toward your purchase. It usually gets credited to your down payment or closing costs.
Question: What can I do to protect my deposit?
Answer: You protect your earnest money deposit by understanding the contract before you sign it and by meeting every deadline after you do and keeping contingencies in effect.
Keep the inspection, appraisal, loan, title, and other contingencies you need. Don’t remove a contingency because the seller or agent says it will make your offer stronger. Once contingencies are waived or removed, recovering your deposit can become much harder.
Question: What are liquidated damages?
Answer: Liquidated damages are a pre-agreed amount of money the parties identify as compensation if one side breaches the contract.
In a California purchase, a liquidated-damages clause may allow the seller to keep the buyer’s earnest money deposit if the buyer defaults after removing the applicable contingencies. It is designed to compensate the seller without requiring a long argument over exactly how much the breach cost.
That does not mean the seller automatically gets the deposit whenever a transaction fails. If the buyer cancels under a valid contingency, the deposit may still be refundable. The contract, deadlines, notices and reason for cancellation all matter.
The practical lesson is simple. Read the liquidated-damages paragraph before you remove contingencies. Once you do, your EMD may be at risk if you walk away without a contractual right to do so.
Question: I had a buyer in contract for my property, no contingencies, and they couldn’t get a loan and couldn’t close. I had a backup offer on the property for the same amount with contingencies, and they ended up closing. Can I keep the first buyer’s deposit?
Answer: Yes, but … karma anyone?
Buyer one removed everything and then failed to close, which is default. California’s forms have liquidated damages boilerplate that may let you keep the deposit even though you resold at the same number. Liquidated damages are the amount agreed to in advance for a failed transaction, and they are not capped by the gap between your first contract and your resale.
Each week in America Answers, Inman contributor America Foy answers questions from the industry at large and offers advice on how to handle the situation.
Have questions? Email America Foy
America Foy is a broker associate at The Grubb Co. Get connected on LinkedIn and Instagram.