Quick Read

  • A Massachusetts lawsuit between Lamacchia Realty and Chinatti Realty Group involves allegations of unfair referral fees, agent misclassification and excessive brokerage oversight.
  • A judge found that Chinatti deliberately destroyed relevant CRM records, criticized her credibility and referred potential wiretap violations to the state attorney general for review.
  • The parties are battling over nine summary judgment motions, with Chinatti disputing the sanctions findings and attributing the lost records to a Zillow-required CRM migration. The court has yet to rule.
An AI tool created this summary, which was based on the text of the article and checked by an editor.

A yearslong legal battle involving two Massachusetts brokerages and a group of agents who left one firm for the other has hit a crossroads.

A yearslong legal battle involving two Massachusetts real estate brokerages and a group of agents who left one firm for the other has reached a crossroads, with the parties now fighting over whether substantial portions of the case should be dismissed or proceed toward a jury trial.

The bitter regional dispute pits Lamacchia Realty, a prominent Boston-area brokerage with more than 800 agents, against Chinatti Realty Group, a Chelmsford-based independent brokerage led by Lisa Chinatti that says it has more than 125 agents. While separate from the high-profile litigation over private listings and multiple listing services that has dominated industry headlines, the case touches on similar industry tensions around agent recruiting, brokerage oversight and the handling of client data.

At the center of the latest legal fight is a September ruling in which a Massachusetts judge found that Chinatti “deliberately and intentionally” caused the destruction of CRM records relevant to allegations brought by former agents who joined competing brokerage Lamacchia Realty.

In filings submitted Nov. 2, Lamacchia Realty and the former agents asked Middlesex Superior Court to deny nine summary judgment motions filed by Chinatti and her brokerage, arguing that allowing the motions to succeed could undermine the court’s sanctions ruling. Chinatti’s attorneys oppose the request, contending that the missing records would not have helped the plaintiffs overcome legal deficiencies in their claims.

A dispute over agents, commissions and brokerage oversight

The lawsuit, filed in August 2024, stems from a dispute involving former Chinatti Realty Group agents who joined Lamacchia Realty, along with former Chinatti sales director Jason Posnick, who eventually left Chinatti’s company and joined Lamacchia Realty as its director of sales. Anthony Lamacchia told Inman that Posnick left the company approximately six weeks ago to launch a coaching business with a partner.

The former agents allege that Chinatti Realty Group imposed unfair contractual provisions, including referral fees of 75 to 85 percent on certain transactions involving company-generated leads that agents continued working with after leaving the brokerage.

They also allege that Chinatti Realty Group treated them more like employees than independent contractors, closely monitoring their daily activities, imposing performance requirements and exercising control beyond what they contend was appropriate for their classification under Massachusetts law.

Lamacchia Realty has also brought an unjust enrichment claim, alleging that Chinatti Realty Group benefited financially from disputed referral fees and commission arrangements involving agents who had moved to Lamacchia.

In a public statement about the litigation, Lamacchia Realty said it has paid Chinatti Realty Group more than $350,000 in referral fees on behalf of former agents, along with another $113,443 to compensate agents for commissions they allegedly lost.

Chinatti and her brokerage deny the underlying allegations. In a written response to Inman, Chinatti defended her company’s supervision practices, saying many of the policies challenged by the former agents were required to comply with Zillow’s Flex lead-generation program.

She also criticized Lamacchia for financing the former agents’ litigation, arguing that her brokerage’s practices were no different from those of other firms and warning of broader consequences for the industry.

“This should be disturbing to every broker in Massachusetts because if those agents were to prevail, a precedent would be set that could be used against any of them,” Chinatti said.

Lamacchia, meanwhile, said brokers have a legal duty to supervise agents but argued that such oversight crosses a line when it extends beyond real estate transactions and brokerage services into agents’ schedules and daily activities.

“Brokers cannot and should not control agents’ day to day activities, schedule or the manner of conducting business,” Lamacchia told Inman. “They should be treated like true independent contractors.”

Judge finds evidence was deliberately destroyed

The litigation took a significant turn Sept. 15, when Middlesex Superior Court Judge Lynn C. Rooney found that Chinatti “deliberately and intentionally” caused the destruction of CRM records from Real Geeks, a platform the brokerage used to manage leads, monitor agent activity and track communications.

Following evidentiary hearings in July and September, Rooney found that Chinatti knew the records were relevant to the dispute after receiving a demand letter in November 2022 but failed to preserve them. The missing data could have documented agents’ daily activities, communications with management and the extent of the brokerage’s oversight.

Chinatti disputed the findings in her response to Inman, saying Zillow required her brokerage to migrate from Real Geeks to Follow Up Boss to remain in its Flex program. According to Chinatti, Zillow paid a third-party vendor to handle the migration, but certain records could not be transferred to the new platform.

The judge also sharply criticized Chinatti’s credibility, citing numerous inconsistencies in her testimony that were contradicted by documentary evidence.

“I do not credit the testimony of Lisa Chinatti. I found her to be completely incredible due to the countless inconsistencies in her testimony,” Rooney wrote.

The court’s findings described a system in which Chinatti and Posnick monitored agents’ CRM activity, conducted frequent audits and imposed consequences when agents failed to meet performance requirements. Those consequences included withholding or reassigning leads and requiring additional training.

Rooney also found that agents’ telephone conversations were recorded without participants being advised, including calls involving consumers, financial institutions and attorneys. In a footnote, the judge said she had forwarded the ruling to the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Criminal Bureau for review of potential wiretap violations.

Chinatti disputed the court’s account of the recordings in her response to Inman, saying the calls were recorded through Zillow’s lead programs and stored on Zillow’s website.

“Despite what Judge Rooney wrote, there was never a single call recorded between attorneys, lenders or financial institutions,” Chinatti said.

The court did not determine that criminal violations had occurred. 

Although Rooney found that the destruction of CRM records unfairly prejudiced the plaintiffs, she declined their request for a default judgment against the defendants. Instead, the judge ruled that the plaintiffs were entitled, at minimum, to a forceful instruction telling jurors that the destroyed evidence would have been unfavorable to Chinatti and her brokerage. Rooney also left open the possibility of additional sanctions at trial.

Lamacchia, meanwhile, said the ruling supported the plaintiffs’ longstanding allegations and expressed his belief that Chinatti knowingly destroyed evidence that could have supported their case.

Both sides clash over what happens next

The consequences of Rooney’s ruling are now central to the latest dispute over whether the case should proceed toward trial.

In their Nov. 2 filing, Lamacchia Realty and the former agents argued that granting Chinatti’s motions for summary judgment could undermine the sanctions ruling by allowing claims to be dismissed before a jury could consider the implications of the destroyed evidence.

The plaintiffs contend that unresolved factual disputes warrant a trial and have asked the court to deny nine defense motions for summary judgment, schedule a final pretrial conference and award attorneys’ fees and costs associated with the motions.

Chinatti’s attorneys argue that the missing CRM records would not resolve what they describe as fundamental legal deficiencies in the plaintiffs’ claims.

In their opposition, the defense said Chinatti Realty Group migrated from Real Geeks to Follow Up Boss in December 2024, during which data was lost. The attorneys acknowledged spoliation solely for purposes of responding to the latest motion, while reserving the right to challenge that finding on appeal or in another context.

The defense contends that the missing records would not establish that the agents’ independent contractor agreements were legally unconscionable or overcome statutes of limitations that it argues bar several wage-related claims.

Chinatti’s attorneys maintain that granting summary judgment would resolve claims lacking sufficient legal support and narrow the issues remaining for trial.

Lamacchia told Inman that he hopes the litigation ultimately results in a judgment against Chinatti and financial compensation for the plaintiffs, estimating that their damages run into the millions of dollars.

As of Tuesday, the court had not ruled on the parties’ latest requests, according to the docket reviewed by Inman. The underlying allegations concerning agent classification, compensation and contractual obligations also remain unresolved.

Email AJ LaTrace

Show Comments Hide Comments
Sign up for Inman’s Morning Headlines
What you need to know to start your day with all the latest industry developments
By submitting your email address, you agree to receive marketing emails from Inman.
Success!
Thank you for subscribing to Morning Headlines.
Only 3 days left to register for Inman Connect Las Vegas before prices go up! Don't miss the premier event for real estate pros.Register Now ×
Limited Time Offer: Get 1 year of Inman Select for $199SUBSCRIBE×
Log in
If you created your account with Google or Facebook
Don't have an account?
Forgot your password?
No Problem

Simply enter the email address you used to create your account and click "Reset Password". You will receive additional instructions via email.

Forgot your username? If so please contact customer support at (510) 658-9252

Password Reset Confirmation

Password Reset Instructions have been sent to

Subscribe to The Weekender
Get the week's leading headlines delivered straight to your inbox.
Top headlines from around the real estate industry. Breaking news as it happens.
15 stories covering tech, special reports, video and opinion.
Unique features from hacker profiles to portal watch and video interviews.
Unique features from hacker profiles to portal watch and video interviews.
It looks like you’re already a Select Member!
To subscribe to exclusive newsletters, visit your email preferences in the account settings.
Up-to-the-minute news and interviews in your inbox, ticket discounts for Inman events and more
1-Step CheckoutPay with a credit card
By continuing, you agree to Inman’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

You will be charged . Your subscription will automatically renew for on . For more details on our payment terms and how to cancel, click here.

Interested in a group subscription?
Finish setting up your subscription
×