Agents, pick your paycheck

Realtor Notebook

Inman News®

Like most real estate agents, I get postcards in the mail from real estate companies that are recruiting agents.

The postcards are pretty much the same. They promise that if I go work with the company, I will get to keep more of my commission and that I will pay lower fees and I will have more opportunities and get more business. They all have state-of-the-art technology and training, too.

It never impresses me when companies advertise that they are less expensive. In some cases those lower fees and higher commission splits mean more out-of-pocket expenses. I look at the list of what the company provides and I rarely find anything that I don't have already.

Why would I want a free template Web site when I already have Web sites? Anyone can get a cheap or free e-mail account, yet e-mail accounts are used as selling points, too.

I already have a phone and it fits in my pocket, so I don't really need a desk in an office to put it on, or another phone line to have to check for voicemail.

Free copies are nice, but I know how much a copy costs and am not willing to give up 20 percent to 60 percent of each commission so that I can have free copies.

The $30 dollars a month that I spend on copies at the local copy shop doesn't add up to much, and I save time because the copy shops are close to home and they will make the copies for me and have them ready for pickup when I arrive.

If I have to pay for services that I don't need or use each month then it doesn't really matter how inexpensive they are -- it is still an expense that I don't need to incur.

There are a couple of common business models for real estate companies:

  • There is the model where the company takes a huge chunk of your commission but gives you a place to work, a phone, a front desk, unlimited copies, a bunch of software, and access to a manager whenever the need arises. The environment is almost like corporate America, complete with meetings and co-workers, office gossip, parties and events.
  • Then there is the model where the company lets you keep most of your commission but it gives you nothing unless you pay for it -- and everything seems to be more expensive than it would be if you bought it yourself.

I have learned something important this year: having lower fees makes a difference in the bottom line. After changing real estate companies, my commission splits went up and my expenses went down. I no longer have some of the services that I used to have, but I was not using those services; I was just paying for them. ...CONTINUED

Share with REmessenger

You must login or register to post a comment.

 
Submitted by Brian Block on December 29, 2009 - 1:55pm.

Theresa,

Now is especially the time of year that many agents are looking to make a change as they look back on their gross and net revenues from the previous year.

It is also a busy time for recruiters and brokers who are recruiting experienced agents. I've been experiencing that here for sure.

You mention the two models, which are basically correct. However, I believe there is a third, the one my brokerage offers:

• The model where the company lets you keep most of your commission but it gives you many tools and services for free and others at very low cost, less expensive than if you were to pay for it yourself.

Maybe not a model, since although it has worked very well for us, I haven't seen many instances of it being replicated.

Best wishes for 2010!

 
Submitted by Jeri Gutner on December 29, 2009 - 2:00pm.

Jeri Gutner
You must be at Keller Williams . . . correct?

 
Submitted by Joseph Kazickas on December 29, 2009 - 2:13pm.

If I was an agent considering a switch the first thing I would investigate is who controls the localized keyword domain names relevant to their market... aspenproperties.com, hamptonsrentals.com as examples, and then if a real estate brokerage business has been built up around those domains it's a no brainer, whatever the split. Ultimately there will be no better brand than a localized keyword domain name to serve as a consistent generator of business.

 
Submitted by John Rakoci on December 29, 2009 - 2:42pm.

I made the change in '08 to a great independent. Fees are zero, great split, nearly everything provided,,, after all those years paying and paying for things there were not wanted or used on top of a franchise fee too. The franchise website received more hits and leads but they were distributed to a lot more agents. The franchise fee was on top of everything else and never deserved. This company takes much better care of me and more importantly, my clients!

 
Submitted by Goran Forss on December 29, 2009 - 3:21pm.

Good article and good points. We made the switch this year from the old traditional brokerage with all their overhead expenses to one of the fastest growing nationwide 100% commission companies - Allison James Estates and Homes. Ok, it's not 100% (as there is a small monthly fee), but I calculated it to be 99.975% for me. Darn close to 100% fee though. With the big brokerage I was at approx 82% after they subtracted commission split, franchise fees, marketing fees, junk fees etc.

This company is not for everyone though. If you must have an office and if you're brand new agent, I would probably recommend a traditional brokerage. If you mostly work from your home and are pretty independent, it works great.

http://www.teamforss.com

 
Submitted by Teresa Boardman on December 29, 2009 - 5:20pm.

Jeri - no I am not with Keller Williams. I am with Saint Paul Home Realty a very small boutique brokerage and I love it. It is a perfect fit with everything I need . . which isn't much.

 
Submitted by Steve Baal on December 30, 2009 - 2:20am.

Teresa, I concur with the excellent points you made. I made the change to a large independent at the start of '09, and this year my sales went up, my overhead went down and as a result I made more money, which has allowed me to invest more in marketing ME. And that should make ME more successful going forward. Isn't that the primary goal?. I also agree with Goran's remarks, being in a similar situation with a brokerage that charges a minimal monthly fee and a very reasonable split. Not exactly 100%, but close enough not to quibble or incite me to go out on my own (which in my situation frankly doesn't seem cost effective). The services I need, including ongoing training, are mostly available for free. However, as Goran mentioned, that type of brokerage is not for the new or the faint of heart. It's for experienced, self motivated, self directed, disciplined individuals who don't require pep talks, hand holding or motivational meetings. All that said, whatever works best for YOU is the model you should follow.

 
Submitted by Jim Crumbaugh on December 30, 2009 - 5:50am.

James A. Crumbaugh III, CEO
12653 SW County RD 769
Suite F
Lake Suzy, FL 34269
1-866-463-5780

I think you might find our business model quite unique and inspiring. We are a truly National Internet Based Real Estate Brokerage. Take a look at our web site and decide for yourself.
www.AllisonJamesInc.com