Let’s say out loud how ridiculous this has gotten.
The largest residential brokerage in the world is suing our industry’s MLSs. Fifteen federal lawsuits in eight states. The MLSs are suing back, and eight of them filed first. Millions of dollars are going to lawyers on both sides.
Now ask the only question that matters: Which part of this helps a family sell their home? None of it. Nobody selling a house asked for this fight, and none of it is being done for their benefit.
Come on, people. Wake up. We are in court arguing over who controls the listing while the person who owns the house waits out in the hallway.
Here’s what we need to do.
First, NAR should retire the Clear Cooperation Policy, the national rule that started this. It was written in 2019 with good intentions, and I said so in my last column. But look at what it did. It turned “where do we advertise this home?” into a rule with fines attached. It pushed listings out of sight and into in-house networks. And it handed us the fight we are in right now.
Second, put the choice back where it belongs: with the seller, in writing, in plain words. That part I can help with today.
A gift for you: A listing agreement that clears up private listing options
Agents in our program kept bringing us the same confusion.
- What counts as a private listing?
- What does Clear Cooperation allow and what does it forbid?
- What do I say when a seller wants privacy, and how do I protect myself when they choose it?
There was no single document that answered those questions at the kitchen table. So we wrote one for them: a complete listing agreement that lays out the seller’s private listing options, the benefits and the costs, and puts the decision in the seller’s own hands.
The one thing both sides already agree on
Compass says only the law and the homeowner should decide how a home is marketed. MLS leaders say publicly marketed homes should stay visible to every broker and every buyer, and that sold data has to reach the appraisers and lenders who depend on it. Art Carter of California Regional MLS said it plainly: “At some point, you’ve got to say, this is a cooperative.”
Those two ideas only collide when the homeowner is left out of the room. A seller who understands the trade-off and still wants privacy is making a choice. A seller who was never told there was a trade-off isn’t choosing anything.
That is the gap. For all the arguing about seller choice, the missing piece has been a plain page that lets a seller make one.
What the agreement does
Section 13 of the listing agreement is called Marketing and Showing Choice. The seller initials one of two options:
- Open market. On the MLS and shown by agents from any company.
- On the MLS with an exclusive showing period. Every agent can see the listing exists, but for a set time only the listing office shows it. This is the status I proposed in my last column.
Then come the parts that matter.
The benefits of the exclusive showing period are listed in plain words: more privacy, fewer strangers walking through the house, one company handling every showing.
So are the costs. Fewer buyers can mean less competition and lower offers. The home may take longer to sell. And then the one nobody enjoys saying out loud: The buyer will most likely come from the listing broker’s own company, which may create dual agency and may mean the broker is paid on both sides. The seller initials that they read it.
If an agent from another company has a buyer, they call the listing agent and ask to co-broke for that buyer. The listing agent then calls the seller and asks if that’s OK. The seller decides each time. The door belongs to the owner, and the owner can open the home to every agent at any point with a written notice.
Last, the seller writes down, in their own words, why they made the choice.
Why this protects everyone in the fight
The seller gets the truth before deciding, which is what we owed them all along.
The agent gets a signed instruction. If a seller later says they were steered into limiting showings, the agent has the seller’s initials and the seller’s own reasons. If an MLS questions the marketing, the agent can show exactly whose decision it was. And if an MLS still tries to fine you for following that instruction, let a court decide which comes first: an MLS rule, or the listing agent’s fiduciary duty to the client, the seller.
The broker gets the conflict of interest on paper, disclosed up front, which is where it protects the firm.
The MLS gets the listing on Day 1, and the sold data at closing, and the door to cooperation stays open, one phone call at a time, by the owner’s choice.
And Compass, along with every brokerage that runs a private network, gets what it has asked for: the homeowner deciding. A seller-choice program is at its strongest when the choice is documented this plainly.
What it won’t do
It won’t end 15 lawsuits. It doesn’t override your MLS rules or your state law. Washington, Wisconsin and Connecticut passed private listing laws this year, and New York’s bill is waiting on the governor, so the second option may be off the table where you work. The agreement itself says that any disclosure form required by law or by your MLS controls.
An invitation to the people in charge
NAR, you just met in New Orleans and approved four new MLS policies on data feeds, data use and copyright. Clear Cooperation was not one of them. Your president told the board that NAR’s role is to “support and strengthen, not run, the MLS ecosystem.” Retiring the Clear Cooperation Policy is that principle in action.
It’s OK to say the intention was good and the outcome was not. Take the national mandate off the books, and let each MLS and its brokers write a rule that fits their market. Leave it in place, and history will point to it as the seed that undid decades of what we built together.
MLS executives, you have spent decades building the cooperative. Consider asking for the seller’s signed, informed election before a fine is ever discussed.
Leaders of brokerages with private networks, put the costs and the both-sides disclosure in front of every seller in words this plain, and nobody can question whose choice it was.
None of this is new. It is what good agents have always done. They told the owner the truth, let the owner decide, and wrote it down. The judges will rule on the rules. What we say at the kitchen table is still ours to get right, and we can start today.
The views and opinions expressed here are those of the contributor and separate from the Inman newsroom.
Darryl Davis is the CEO of Darryl Davis Seminars. Get connected on Facebook or YouTube.