Quick Read

  • Seven MLSs are fighting to keep their lawsuit against Compass in New York, arguing that splitting the cases would increase costs and duplicate legal efforts.
  • Compass has filed 15 lawsuits across 11 federal districts, while both sides dispute whether deadline extensions were used to negotiate or prepare for litigation.
  • The venue battle could determine where key antitrust questions are decided, with courts yet to rule on the legality of the disputed MLS rules.
An AI tool created this summary, which was based on the text of the article and checked by an editor.

Seven MLSs are pushing back against Compass’ efforts to dismiss their lawsuit in New York or move claims to courts across the country.

Seven multiple listing services are pushing back against Compass’ efforts to dismiss their lawsuit in New York or move their claims to federal courts across the country, the latest development in an increasingly complex legal battle over rules governing how real estate listings are shared and marketed.

In a filing Wednesday, the MLS organizations argued that Compass is attempting to fragment a nationwide dispute over cooperation rules into separate proceedings, creating significant costs and duplication of effort.

The filing follows Compass’ decision earlier this month to file 15 separate federal lawsuits against MLSs across 11 judicial districts, escalating a conflict over restrictions on publicly marketing office-exclusive listings.

“Compass’s effort to scatter this dispute across multiple courts would create unnecessary complexity and expense without changing the fundamental issue at stake,” Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service CEO Jeff Bosch said in a statement shared with Inman and other trade media Thursday.

Compass maintains that the MLS organizations operate independently, enforce different rules and serve distinct regional markets. The brokerage argues that disputes over those rules should be resolved in the jurisdictions where the organizations operate, rather than consolidated in New York.

The competing arguments were laid out in a series of letters to U.S. District Judge Mary Kay Vyskocil, who on Thursday denied requests for pre-motion conferences and directed Compass to file its anticipated motions to dismiss or sever and transfer the claims by Dec. 3. The filings also offer conflicting accounts of the talks that preceded the lawsuits.

A fight over where the lawsuits belong

The dispute over jurisdiction has been brewing since early October, when California Regional Multiple Listing Service filed a lawsuit against Compass in the Southern District of New York, seeking a declaration that its cooperation rules comply with federal and state antitrust laws. CRMLS filed the lawsuit Oct. 5, one day before Compass’ deadline to comply with a demand letter threatening antitrust litigation.

Compass responded on Oct. 16 by filing its own antitrust lawsuit against CRMLS in California, alleging that the MLS’ rules unlawfully restrict competition and limit the marketing options available to homeowners and real estate professionals. Four days later, Compass notified the New York court that it intended to seek dismissal of CRMLS’ lawsuit or have the case transferred to California.

Six MLSs filed a separate declaratory judgment lawsuit against Compass in New York on Oct. 21, while OneKey MLS joined the CRMLS lawsuit six days later. California-based MLSListings joined the six-MLS suit on Oct. 30, bringing that coalition to seven plaintiffs: Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, BridgeMLS, Canopy MLS, Doorify MLS, Hive MLS, MLSListings and REcolorado.

Compass has argued that adding OneKey, a New York-based MLS, to the CRMLS lawsuit was a procedural maneuver intended to strengthen the case for keeping the California dispute in New York.

In a Nov. 4 letter, CRMLS and OneKey disputed that characterization, arguing that Compass itself established the connection to New York through a coordinated legal campaign originating from its headquarters there.

The MLSs pointed to demand letters Compass sent on Sept. 8, which they described as nearly word-for-word identical, bearing the same subject line, legal arguments and Oct. 6 deadline. Each warned that Compass “will spend millions of dollars to sue” the recipient “and other MLSs” unless it stopped penalizing agents for publicly marketing office-exclusive listings.

In their Nov. 18 filing, the seven MLS plaintiffs also noted that Compass is seeking to move litigation away from its own headquarters and from a judicial district where it has chosen to pursue related litigation against Zillow.

Compass, however, argues that its lawsuits involve different parties and legal claims, including demands for monetary damages and challenges to additional MLS rules beyond those identified in the New York proceedings. The company maintains that those differences prevent the declaratory judgment actions from resolving the broader controversy.

The increasingly contentious exchanges between Compass and the MLSs have also drawn a pointed response from the judge overseeing both New York cases.

“The Parties are admonished to refrain from filing seriatim updates on each and every development in this wide-ranging litigation,” Vyskocil wrote in a footnote to her Nov. 19 scheduling order.

Competing accounts of a failed negotiation

In September, Compass sent demand letters to numerous MLSs warning that it would pursue federal antitrust litigation unless they agreed to stop fining or otherwise penalizing real estate professionals for publicly marketing office-exclusive listings. Several organizations requested extensions of Compass’ original Oct. 6 deadline.

In a Nov. 13 letter to the court, Compass attorneys alleged that the MLSs used those extensions to prepare an improperly anticipatory lawsuit intended to deprive the brokerage of its preferred forum, though Compass had granted the extensions as a good-faith professional courtesy.

The brokerage attached email correspondence between its legal team and an attorney representing several MLS organizations to support its account.

In a Sept. 18 email, attorney Mitchell Skinner, representing ARMLS, Doorify, Hive, OneKey and Unlock MLS, requested a draft release from Compass following a conversation with its attorneys. In an Oct. 5 email, Compass Chief Legal Officer Ethan Glass confirmed an extension of the deadline for those organizations until Oct. 20.

Compass also told the court that other MLSs received extensions. BridgeMLS was given until Oct. 30 to respond, REcolorado until Nov. 6 and Canopy MLS until Oct. 20. MLSListings received an extension until Oct. 28.

That meant BridgeMLS and REcolorado were still within their extended deadlines when they joined the lawsuit against Compass on Oct. 21, a point the brokerage cited in arguing that the MLSs had used the additional time to prepare litigation rather than negotiate a resolution.

The correspondence documents discussions between the parties and the extensions Compass granted, although it does not independently establish whether the MLSs intended to negotiate a resolution or were preparing to file suit.

In their Nov. 18 response, the seven MLS plaintiffs rejected Compass’ characterization of the discussions, alleging that the company had offered no meaningful room for negotiation.

According to their attorneys, the organizations were effectively presented with a choice between abandoning their cooperation rules in exchange for what they described as a “toothless” release or remaining exposed to the threat of antitrust litigation, without knowing when or where Compass might sue.

The MLSs also pointed to an Oct. 22 court filing in which Compass said it had “not decided whether to file any other cases,” despite having threatened litigation against numerous MLS organizations. Three weeks later, Compass filed its 15 lawsuits.

The MLSs argue that their decision to seek judicial declarations that their rules are lawful was a response to those threats rather than an attempt to gain an unfair procedural advantage.

Where the cases stand

The venue fight could determine whether the New York court addresses the central legal questions in the MLSs’ cases or whether their claims are split among courts across the country. The seven MLS plaintiffs argue that severing their claims would create seven proceedings in five judicial districts, each requiring overlapping evidence.

In addition to the two declaratory judgment actions in New York, Compass has pursued affirmative antitrust litigation against CRMLS in California and against 15 additional MLS organizations in lawsuits filed Nov. 12.

Those newer cases include all seven plaintiffs in the ARMLS-led New York lawsuit, as well as OneKey, which Compass sued separately in the Eastern District of New York. CRMLS is the only plaintiff in the two New York proceedings not included in the Nov. 12 batch, having already been sued by Compass in California.

In their Nov. 18 filing, the seven MLS plaintiffs noted that three organizations targeted in Compass’ lawsuits — Bay East Association of Realtors, Contra Costa Association of Realtors and Regional MLS of Minnesota — had not received the demand letters sent to other MLSs earlier in the fall.

Other defendants include Combined L.A./Westside MLS; San Diego MLS; My Florida Regional MLS, which operates as Stellar MLS; and Houston Realtors Information Service, the MLS subsidiary of the Houston Association of Realtors.

The litigation follows Compass’ earlier legal challenges involving Northwest Multiple Listing Service and Zillow, which raised related questions about brokerage competition, listing access and restrictions on how properties can be marketed.

The wave of lawsuits has also put a spotlight on legal costs. CRMLS previously announced plans for an MLS Cooperation Legal Defense Fund, while the Council of Multiple Listing Services (CMLS) is establishing a separate nonprofit to help fund MLS legal battles.

Compass International Holdings has also been advertising an opening for a California-admitted litigation attorney. The job ad says the position involves managing civil cases and overseeing outside counsel across its brokerage brands. The listing predates the latest lawsuits.

For now, the cases remain largely in their early stages, with courts yet to rule on the underlying legality of the disputed cooperation rules.

Compass faces a Dec. 3 deadline to file its anticipated motions to dismiss or sever and transfer the claims in the two New York lawsuits. In California, CRMLS has until Dec. 28 to respond to Compass’ antitrust complaint.

Email AJ LaTrace

Show Comments Hide Comments
Sign up for Inman’s Morning Headlines
What you need to know to start your day with all the latest industry developments
By submitting your email address, you agree to receive marketing emails from Inman.
Success!
Thank you for subscribing to Morning Headlines.
Only 3 days left to register for Inman Connect Las Vegas before prices go up! Don't miss the premier event for real estate pros.Register Now ×
Limited Time Offer: Get 1 year of Inman Select for $199SUBSCRIBE×
Log in
If you created your account with Google or Facebook
Don't have an account?
Forgot your password?
No Problem

Simply enter the email address you used to create your account and click "Reset Password". You will receive additional instructions via email.

Forgot your username? If so please contact customer support at (510) 658-9252

Password Reset Confirmation

Password Reset Instructions have been sent to

Subscribe to The Weekender
Get the week's leading headlines delivered straight to your inbox.
Top headlines from around the real estate industry. Breaking news as it happens.
15 stories covering tech, special reports, video and opinion.
Unique features from hacker profiles to portal watch and video interviews.
Unique features from hacker profiles to portal watch and video interviews.
It looks like you’re already a Select Member!
To subscribe to exclusive newsletters, visit your email preferences in the account settings.
Up-to-the-minute news and interviews in your inbox, ticket discounts for Inman events and more
1-Step CheckoutPay with a credit card
By continuing, you agree to Inman’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

You will be charged . Your subscription will automatically renew for on . For more details on our payment terms and how to cancel, click here.

Interested in a group subscription?
Finish setting up your subscription
×