Affordability challenges have radically changed the idea of a starter home, according to Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate’s (BHGRE) 2027 trends report.
The brokerage said today’s first-time buyers no longer assume they’ll be able to buy a second home that meets their future needs because of long-term supply-side challenges, home price growth and the recent run-up in mortgage rates. Whereas first-time buyers in the past may have sacrificed lifestyle for price, BHGRE said that’s no longer the case.
A home doesn’t have to be “move-in perfect,” the brokerage said, but it does need the potential to carry a homebuyer through multiple life stages, including marriage, children and the possibility that those children may live at home past 18, as well as enough space for aging parents.

Ginger Wilcox, BHGRE president
“This new group of buyers aren’t abandoning the idea of a starter home,” the report read. “They’re rethinking what that first purchase needs to deliver. A smaller home may still be the right financial decision, but its ability to adapt becomes increasingly important. A spare bedroom might pull double duty as an office and then morph into a nursery.”
“The distinction is significant,” it added. “Rather than purchasing with the expectation of moving up and out in a few years, these buyers are considering whether their first home can remain the right home for longer.”
The brokerage found that nearly a third of first-time homebuyers are willing to accept less square footage if the home otherwise meets their needs. They’re also open to purchasing a fixer-upper, with the idea that they’ll be able to make incremental cosmetic upgrades (47 percent). However, homebuyers aren’t budging on the bigger features, like updated kitchens and bathrooms, and newer roofs and HVAC systems.
In a phone call with Inman, BHGRE President Ginger Wilcox said this trend — which they call the non-starter generation — has been building for the better part of a decade.
The first signal, Wilcox said, was a steadily increasing homeowner tenure. The National Association of Realtors (NAR) data revealed that from 1987 to 2008, the typical homebuyer stayed in their home for six years. The median tenure started rising after the housing crash, reaching a high of 12 years in 2026.
“What we saw in our report is that first-time home buyers are looking for a home that they can grow into, and that can be adaptable. They’re placing a lot more functional value on functionality and the long-term livability,” she said. “They’re looking for a place that can fit different stages of life. Family needs may start with a baby. There are many people in this sort of sandwich generation where they also have to think about aging parents, and so they are looking for spaces that will evolve for that, too, alongside children.”
Wilcox said this trend is heightened by the fact that the typical first-time homebuyer is older (40, to be exact), meaning they likely have a more complex set of wants and needs than their predecessors who often stepped into homeownership in their late 20s.
“First-time home buyers historically were maybe moving into their home because they were just having their first child. Now today they’re very established,” she said. “Adaptability continues to be really king here. What we’re seeing is people want to make changes that are smaller, that are more adaptable over time, that enable them to fit where they’re at in that kind of moment, and then extend into so they’re seeing that change over a longer time horizon.”
The convergence of affordability and demographic changes means that agents need to shift how they help first-time homebuyers shop.
Square footage should take a backseat, Wilcox said, in favor of helping homebuyers see how various spaces throughout a home can serve multiple functions over time. She said it’s also important to get a clear picture of buyers’ immediate and long-term needs, whether they anticipate having a multigenerational household, and whether they’re comfortable with the process of steadily turning their starter home into a forever — or long-term — home with small upgrades or major renovations.
“The fundamental change that we’re seeing in consumer behavior is that what they’re looking for goes beyond just the price of the home,” she said. “Consumers are increasingly measuring the value of not just appreciation potential, which has historically been where the focus is, but how it supports the flexibility of life and how you make sure that spaces ultimately are working harder for you.”