Imagine typing “beautifully updated throughout” into the MLS remarks. The home draws multiple offers, then appraises below the contract price. Now you’re calling the seller to find out when the kitchen was redone and whether they still have the invoices.
Those three words didn’t cause the appraisal to come in low, but they give the appraiser almost nothing to check.
- Were the cabinets replaced or just repainted?
- Were both bathrooms remodeled?
- What was left original?
Those are questions you can ask while you’re still walking through the house with the seller.
A need to be more specific: UAD 3.6 appraisal changes
On Nov. 2, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac replaced the appraisal report most conventional loans have used for years. The new standard is called Uniform Appraisal Dataset (UAD) 3.6. It asks the appraiser to record much more about the house itself: what was updated, when the work was done and what shape the major parts of the home are in. Condition and quality are now rated separately for the inside and the outside.
Some lenders got permission to keep using the old form until next May, so you’ll see both for a while. The direction is set either way. Appraisals are moving from general impressions to specific, dated facts.
You don’t need to learn the appraiser’s software. You do need to know what the new report asks about, because you’re often the first person who can get those answers from the seller.
Collect the facts at the listing appointment
When a seller says, “We redid the kitchen,” ask three questions:
- What did you change?
- When did you do it?
- What did you keep?
“Kitchen updated in 2022” gives you a date. “Replaced the cabinet fronts and installed quartz countertops in 2022, kept the original appliances” tells the appraiser what the work actually involved.
Ask the same questions about the bathrooms, roof, heating and cooling system, water heater and windows. Request any invoices, permits, warranties or plans the seller has retained. If they know what the work cost, record it separately. What they paid and what buyers will pay for the improvement are two different figures.
Keep a short, dated improvement history and note where each detail came from. If the seller says the water heater is “about five years old,” write that it’s a seller estimate. If you later find the installation invoice, update your notes with the confirmed date. Never turn a guess into a date because a form seems to want one.
The best house on the street isn’t a quality rating
Explain this one to sellers early. An appraiser rates construction quality on the home’s design, materials and workmanship, not on how it compares with the neighbors. A home can stand out to buyers in its subdivision and still carry the same quality rating as the houses around it.
Buyers still react to how a home compares with its neighbors, and that shows up in price. The quality rating doesn’t care what’s next door. Don’t confuse being the best house on the street with being a better-built house. That’s one more reason to describe the work and materials as specifically as you can.
Check the old listing before you write the new one
If the 2021 MLS listing calls the roof “new,” check whether the seller is talking about the same roof. Carrying that remark forward in 2026 makes it sound like the roof was just replaced. Use the right MLS fields, add the date and scope in the remarks where useful, and keep the paperwork in your listing file so you can find it later.
Keep your pricing notes, too. Save the MLS numbers for the closed sales you used and write a sentence about why each one is relevant. “Same floor plan and similar lot, with original bathrooms” gives the appraiser a place to start.
Note any seller concessions you can verify, and flag anything you still need to check. At closing, report verified concessions in your own listing where your MLS rules allow. The record you leave may be the comparable someone else pulls next year.
Have the information ready when the appraisal is ordered
Ask the buyer’s lender early which appraisal format the loan will use and how long appraisals are taking right now, and build that into your deadlines. Appraisers are still getting used to the new report. Try to keep the buyer from switching lenders late in the deal, because a new lender can mean a new appraisal.
Once the appraiser has been engaged, ask the lender or appraisal management company how to share relevant information. Start with your dated improvement history, supporting documents and a short set of comparable sales with notes on why you included them. Leave any desired value out of the packet. The appraiser decides what to use and reaches an independent opinion.
Vague claims are not evidence
The new report doesn’t make you responsible for the value, and better documentation doesn’t guarantee a higher number. Value isn’t created at the appraisal. It’s checked there.
At your next listing appointment, take a few minutes to walk through the updates with the seller. When the appraisal is ordered, you’ll already have the dates, the details and the paperwork to answer for the house.
Deb Siefkin is a practicing broker and founder of RightSize Realty Associates. Connect with Deb on LinkedIn and Instagram.