Amid unprecedented affordability challenges in the housing market, home insurers saw premium revenue climb twice as fast as claims payouts during the past five years, according to a new report from Americans for Financial Reform, a nonpartisan advocacy group.
The report, provocatively titled “Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis,” surveyed market data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners and found premium revenue rose 59 percent between 2021 and 2025, from $114 billion to $181 billion. During the same period, claim payouts rose only 28 percent, and the share of premiums paid back as claims dropped from 69 percent to 55 percent.
The largest gaps between premiums and payouts occurred in two of the insurance industry’s biggest markets, Texas and Florida.
In Texas, premiums collected rose 78 percent from $11.2 billion to $20 billion, while claim payouts fell 23 percent. In Florida, premiums rose 64 percent to $18.7 billion while payouts fell 67 percent.
In addition to what the report presents as “unnecessarily high prices,” it cited faulty claims handling as part of the insurance industry’s problematic behavior. Insurers closed 30 percent of claims without payment from 2021 to 2025 and delayed more than 22 percent of payments past 60 days in the report’s findings.
“Insurance companies are maximizing profits by raising rates, withdrawing from communities, and closing a staggering number of claims without payment,” Elyse Schupak, policy advocate with Public Citizen’s Climate Program and one of the authors of the report, said in a statement. “After spending years pointing to climate change and rising disaster costs to justify offering policyholders less protection at a higher price, the insurance industry is reaping record profits. Insurance companies preach about protecting households, but the numbers reveal that the industry is actively padding its bottom line at their expense.”
The report’s authors make the following recommendations in response to ongoing increases in homeowners insurance premiums:
- Establish a minimum loss ratio for property insurers
- Strengthen oversight of rate increases
- Require insurers to invest in and reward resilience
- Increase oversight of insurer claims handling
- Increase transparency over insurer underwriting, pricing and claims decisions
Insurance premiums were up at least 50 percent over five years in 19 of 30 metros analyzed in a recent report from Zillow and Thumbtack. Dallas saw the highest increases at 75 percent in that report, with Tampa following at 71 percent.
In Houston, Phoenix, Denver and Nashville, homeowners now pay more for insurance each year than for property taxes.
Insurance costs also became an unanticipated flashpoint during the recent midterm elections, according to an analysis by Insurify’s Julia Taliesin. Its mid-year home insurance analysis found that 26 percent of survey respondents said home insurance costs would play a role in determining how they would vote.