Affordability woes have knocked homebuilder sentiment to a 14-year low, according to the National Association of Home Builders’ November Housing Market Index.
The HMI, produced in collaboration with Wells Fargo, measures current and expected new single-family home sales and homebuyer traffic on a 0-to-100 scale, with readings above 50 signaling strong homebuilder confidence. This month’s readings were dismal: current sales conditions fell six points to 28, six-month sales projections dropped two points to 30, and buyer activity declined two points to 16.
Overall homebuilder confidence is at 25 — the third time since November 1990 and the lowest reading since April 2012.

Bill Owens
NAHB’s chairman and chief economist said November’s HMI reflects labor and supply chain challenges, and the impact of rising mortgage rates.
“Builders are confronting multiple challenges in today’s economy,” Chairman Bill Owens said in a written statement on Tuesday. “Stepped-up immigration enforcement is keeping legal workers off job sites, deepening labor shortages and driving up costs. Higher fuel prices are prompting subcontractors to raise their rates sharply, and with fewer buyers in the market, more builders are scaling back construction.”
Added Chief Economist Robert Dietz, “The housing market faces a range of supply-side challenges, including building material costs pushed higher by tariffs, an ongoing shortage of construction workers and excessive regulations that undermine housing affordability. Mortgage rates above 7 percent, softer consumer confidence and an uncertain economic outlook are holding buyers back.”
The NAHB said homebuilders are responding to waning homebuyer traffic with price cuts and other sales incentives. Forty-six percent of homebuilders reduced prices by a median of 6 percent, and 68 percent offered sales incentives. Both measures are at a six-year high, the report said.
Realtor.com provided additional insight into homebuilder incentives, noting that new-home buyers are faring better than existing-home buyers on their mortgage rates.
According to the portal, typical new-home buyers secured an average mortgage rate of 6.19 percent, compared with 6.68 percent for existing-home buyers. Realtor.com said this advantage comes from homebuilders connecting buyers with lenders that offer lower rates or paying for a rate buydown on the buyer’s behalf.

Joel Berner
In October, Realtor.com said the recent increase in mortgage rates has complicated the math for homebuyers, with a household earning the median income needing to spend 0.6 percentage points more of its income on the typical mortgage payment (34.3 percent) than it did last year (33.7 percent). The portal estimated that buyers can protect themselves against mortgage rate fluctuations by adding a $130 buffer to their budgets, assuming they’re purchasing a median-priced home with a 10 percent down payment.
When it comes to new-home buyers specifically, rate buydowns offer an added advantage, with a savings of $117 per month on a $400,000 purchase with 10 percent down.
“Builders have adjusted to a market where affordability is still a major hurdle, but that adjustment isn’t always visible in the listing price,” Realtor.com Senior Economist Joel Berner said in a Tuesday report. “Reduced mortgage rates can help make a new home more affordable for buyers while allowing builders to hold asking prices relatively steady.”
“Mortgage-rate incentives can make a meaningful difference in what a buyer pays each month, but it’s important to understand how long the lower rate lasts,” he added. “A temporary buydown can provide relief early on, while a lower rate fixed for the life of the loan offers a different kind of savings.”
New-home buyers are expected to keep the upper hand compared to existing-home buyers, even as homebuilder activity slows. The completion rate for new single-family homes fell 11.0 percent year over year in September, Realtor.com said, and new construction’s share of the market has slid from 17.2 percent to 16.7 percent.