We’ve all been on the bad side of a deal that falls through due to financing. It’s discouraging for the buyer and disastrous for the seller — the price impact is almost never recoverable, and the reputational damage with clients and cooperating agents can continue to resonate in subsequent failed deals and lost opportunities.
That’s why connecting with the best lenders in your market is one of the foundational moves you must make to take care of yourself, your clients and your business. Here’s what to look for, plus thoughts on lender choice from my friends and colleagues from the Sofi Real Estate Advisory Council.
Having a lender vs. having a network
Many real estate agents have a favorite lender. Sometimes it’s your buddy, Chad, because he brings doughnuts to every brokerage meeting. Sometimes it’s the brokerage’s in-house lender.
However, in most cases, a one-size-fits-all lender isn’t going to serve your clients best. Different deal types require different strengths, including the ability to work with:
- First-time buyers
- Jumbo mortgages
- Self-employed buyers
- Buyers rebuilding their credit
- Investors looking for all-inclusive loans
“I don’t have one preferred lender. I have a bench. Every deal is different, and the best lender for a first-time buyer isn’t necessarily the best lender for a self-employed entrepreneur or a jumbo borrower. My job is to match the financing strategy to the client, not force every client into the same lender,” Scot Drucker, a real estate agent at Compass, told me.
Viviana Cherman, a broker at SERHANT, doesn’t rely on one preferred lender either.
“I have built up a trusted network of professionals. Every client’s situation is different, and my responsibility is to connect them with the lender who will give them the best opportunity to succeed,” Cherman said.
Top agents match the lender to the deal, not the other way around. They cultivate relationships with different lenders who specialize in different loan types and borrower profiles or with a mortgage broker who can reach out to specialists for practically any type of loan. That creates options when things get complicated or a deal starts to go south.
The closing table is the only finish line that matters
Pre-approvals are easy, but closing is hard. What separates strong, specialized lenders from also-rans is their skills in problem-solving, underwriting foresight, and communication under pressure and time constraints.
Ask your potential lender the following questions before you pass along their name to a client:
- How often do your deals actually close?
- What happens when something breaks mid-transaction?
- How do you ensure 24/7 communication when it’s time to write an offer?
A lender’s true value doesn’t show when you’re working with the perfect client under the perfect market conditions. It shows when the deal is at risk.
“Most of my buyer clients feel like the financing is the most stressful part of the deal. Having a lender who knows how to walk them through the process, anticipate and navigate through roadblocks and deliver on promises can make or break the entire homebuying process,” D’Ann Melnick, an agent at eXp Realty, said.
“A great lender can make or break a deal before the home is even under contract. My go-to lenders will get on the phone with the list agent, explain the buyer’s financial strength and soothe worries about more complicated mortgages (like VA loans). They don’t just close; they help the buyer win to begin with,” Alley Buscemi, owner of AlleyCo Homes, Compass, told me.
Virtual and out-of-town lenders: Does it matter?
Many real estate agents shy away from recommending a virtual or out-of-town lender, believing that local market knowledge provides essential context during the appraisal and underwriting processes. However, local knowledge only matters when it’s paired with execution.
The question to ask yourself: Who can move fastest, communicate most clearly and solve problems in real time? Many strong remote lenders have better processes, availability and scalability. That translates into more responsiveness, better systems and more comprehensive underwriting strength for clients.
One agent told me how her mindset changed.
“I’ve been extremely reluctant to use an out-of-state lender. In the competitive market in Northern Virginia, it’s imperative to use every advantage you can and a local lender is an advantage,” Lindsey Schmidt, an agent at Fathom Realty, told me.
“One of my clients was adamant about working with his lender in Colorado, and I reluctantly accepted. He’s now one of my best lenders. He always had the CTC early, which is great, but what I appreciate the most is his direct communication and personality; my clients love that he doesn’t BS them. He gets to the point and gets the job done.
“Now, when I submit an offer, I get ahead of objections by stating that I have access to him nights and weekends (I do) and that he always has the CTC early. He also calls them rather than waiting for their call. Open communication is key!” Schmidt said.
What does a high-performing lender do?
A high-performing lender will:
- Offer pre-underwriting, not just pre-approval
- Flag income, appraisal gap and credit risks early
- Set realistic expectations with buyers upfront
- Communicate proactively with all stakeholders
- Have a track record of saving deals, not just starting them
“The right lender doesn’t just know loan guidelines; they know people. Every client communicates differently, and the best lending partners adapt their communication style, provide proactive updates, and create confidence throughout the transaction. Combined with disciplined execution and the strength of a trusted institution, that’s what helps turn accepted offers into successful closings,” Jessica Foote, CEO and broker, explained.
How do you find one?
Your due diligence is important in choosing which lenders to recommend. Here’s how to vet and pressure-test potential lending partners before you need them.
- Ask for real metrics, including close rate, average time to close and fallout rate
- Listen for how they handle complex scenarios, not easy deals
- Pay attention to their communication style, speed and availability early on
- Watch how they handle friction, not just how they sell themselves
Don’t forget to ask colleagues for great lenders to contact, especially if you identify a specific gap in your lender network. Once you’ve built your network, here’s how to maintain it:
- Aim for three to five go-to lenders with different specialties
- Regularly re-evaluate their performance and replace if needed
- Set expectations around responsiveness, updates and accountability
- Treat lenders as strategic partners, not just referral recipients
- Ask clients about their experience with any lender you’ve recommended
“One of the most important decisions I make for my clients isn’t just pricing and marketing … it’s connecting them with the right lending partner. Experience is knowing who can solve problems when the transaction gets challenging, not just who can pre-approve a loan. They have proven they can navigate complexity, communicate under pressure and get our clients to the closing table,” said Heather Herr, founder and CEO, Private Real Estate Collection, Team Herr.
The best way to frame your referral
Basing lender recommendations on risk management rather than personal preference — and framing the referral that way to your clients — helps you build trust and get more deals to the closing table. That’s not just good for your clients; it’s good for your commission.
Troy Palmquist is the founder and principal at HomeCode Advisors. Connect with him on LinkedIn.