There’s a growing problem in real estate that almost every brokerage leader, coach, franchise executive and association executive quietly acknowledges — but very few openly discuss.
Agents today say they want mentorship, culture, accountability, training, support and community, yet participation across the industry continues to decline.
TAKE THE INMAN INTEL INDEX SURVEY
They want coaching but skip the calls. They want culture but don’t attend office events. They ask for training but rarely show up for workshops. They want accountability while resisting structure. And they want community while operating increasingly independently.
This challenge is happening everywhere.
Associations are struggling to drive attendance. Brokerages are fighting declining participation in meetings and educational events. Coaches are battling consistency and follow-through. Even some of the industry’s largest brands, offering massive technology and training ecosystems, are finding that many agents simply are not engaging the way they once did.
What makes this even more interesting is that the problem is not isolated to one business model. It’s happening across traditional brick-and-mortar companies, virtual brokerages, independent firms, franchise systems and coaching organizations alike.
Which raises a difficult but important question: Has the industry fundamentally changed how agents consume support?
The industry’s biggest challenge may no longer be attracting agents to support systems — it may be convincing them that participation itself still matters.
As information becomes more accessible and professionals gain greater independence, brokerages, associations, coaches and brands are being forced to rethink a fundamental question: How do you create engagement, accountability and community in a business where participation is increasingly optional?
The shift from physical presence to digital access
For years, success in real estate was closely tied to physical participation.
Agents attended office meetings, caravan tours, live trainings, networking events and coaching sessions because that was where information, opportunity, collaboration and relationships lived. Participation was often viewed as part of the path to growth.
Today, information lives everywhere.
Agents can learn from YouTube, Instagram, podcasts, Facebook groups, AI tools, private masterminds, online communities and text threads without ever stepping into an office or attending a scheduled event.
Knowledge has become instantly accessible, and that accessibility has quietly changed behavior across the industry.
The modern agent increasingly values flexibility over obligation, convenience over structure and on-demand access over scheduled attendance. The industry has evolved into a world where many agents believe they can build an entire business independently, consuming information only when they want it and how they want it.
Can you build culture without participation?
That may become one of the defining leadership questions of the next decade.
For years, many companies operated under the assumption that if they provided the right tools, systems, training and opportunities, engagement would naturally follow. Show up, plug in, participate, and growth would happen.
Today’s reality looks very different.
Access to information has never been easier, yet engagement has never been harder to earn. Simply offering resources is no longer enough. Participation is now a choice, and many agents are choosing flexibility over structure, convenience over commitment and independence over involvement.
The result? Companies can build impressive ecosystems, but culture doesn’t happen because resources exist. Culture happens when people actively engage with one another.
And that’s where many companies are struggling.
Information overload is creating disengagement
In fact, the industry may now be facing an oversaturation problem.
Agents are constantly bombarded with webinars, coaching offers, masterminds, scripts, AI tutorials, social media strategies, CRM systems, productivity tools and educational content from every direction imaginable.
At some point, the abundance itself becomes overwhelming, and overwhelmed agents often disengage entirely.
The rise of the independent brand mindset
The participation crisis also reflects a deeper psychological shift happening within the industry.
Many agents no longer see themselves as brokerage-dependent professionals. Instead, they increasingly view themselves as independent brands operating within larger ecosystems.
That mindset changes everything.
Broker loyalty weakens. Office attendance declines. Independent learning increases. Traditional accountability structures become harder to maintain.
The participation paradox
And yet the irony is impossible to ignore: The agents who consistently participate are often still the ones growing the fastest.
Not because attendance alone creates success, but because engagement creates proximity — proximity to leadership, collaboration, accountability and opportunity.
Real estate has always been an industry accelerated by relationships and repetition. Technology can support those things, but it cannot fully replace them.
The companies that win will solve engagement
The companies that ultimately win the next era of real estate may not necessarily be the ones with the biggest technology stacks.
They may be the companies that figure out how to solve engagement.
That doesn’t mean forcing attendance or returning to outdated mandatory meeting models. It means rethinking how participation itself is designed.
The future may belong to organizations that create flexible learning environments, personalized engagement, smaller communities within larger brands, high-value in-person experiences and accountability systems agents actually want to use.
The challenge now is creating environments where agents choose participation because they find genuine value in it, not because they are required to attend.
Redefining what participation looks like
That may also require leaders to stop measuring engagement by attendance alone.
The future of participation may look less like weekly office meetings and more like intentional micro-communities, niche collaboration groups, digital ecosystems, mentorship circles and personalized growth paths.
But one reality remains unchanged: No agent succeeds entirely alone.
The real crisis isn’t attendance
The brokerages, associations, coaching companies and leaders who figure out how to rebuild meaningful engagement — without relying on outdated structures — may ultimately become the most influential organizations in the industry.
Because the real participation crisis isn’t about attendance.
It’s about connection.
It’s about community.
And in an industry built entirely on relationships, that matters more than ever.
In June, Inman goes deep on real estate teams: what it takes to join one, how to build a team worth joining, and yes, when it’s time to leave. During Teams Month, we’ll be drawing on the best team leaders in the country to bring you the insights, frameworks and hard-won lessons that don’t usually make it into the highlight reel.
Lori Muller is the president of Fathom Realty in Cary, North Carolina. Connect with her on Facebook or LinkedIn.
