Real estate is changing fast, and so must you. Inman Connect San Diego is where you turn uncertainty into strategy — with real talk, real tools and the connections that matter. If you’re serious about staying ahead of the game, this is where you need to be. Register now!
The shift from search engines to answer engines is redefining how agents and brokerages should approach online reputation management.
TAKE THE INMAN INTEL SURVEY FOR JUNE
The real estate industry is experiencing its most significant digital transformation since the advent of online listings. As artificial intelligence reshapes how consumers discover and evaluate services, the role of client reviews has evolved from simple social proof to critical training data for AI systems that will soon recommend or overlook your business.
The new reality: From search to conversation
Traditional search behavior is rapidly changing. Instead of typing “real estate agents near me” and scrolling through results, consumers increasingly ask AI assistants direct questions: “Who’s the best agent for first-time buyers in downtown Austin?” or “Which brokerage knows the most about new construction in Plano?”
This shift represents more than a change in user interface. It’s a fundamental change in how business recommendations are generated. When ChatGPT, Google’s AI Overviews or other AI systems respond to these queries, they’re not ranking websites. They’re synthesizing information from across the internet to provide direct recommendations, and your client reviews are a primary data source.
A study by Netpeak found that over 60 percent of consumers now use AI chatbots for product research before making purchase decisions. For real estate professionals, this means your online reputation isn’t just influencing potential clients who read your reviews. It’s actively training the AI systems that will represent your brand to future prospects.
Reviews as AI training data
Here’s the critical insight most agents miss: AI systems can assess the sentiment of written content, meaning negative or outdated reviews on any platform may cause AI to describe your brand unfavorably. Conversely, detailed, positive reviews with specific outcomes help AI systems understand and communicate your expertise.
AI systems are surprisingly sophisticated at identifying inconsistent claims. If your marketing materials claim exceptional results but independent reviews don’t support these assertions, AI systems will likely favor competitors with stronger evidence. This makes authentic client satisfaction — and the detailed reviews it generates — more valuable than ever.
The most effective reviews for AI training include specific details: transaction timelines, price outcomes, neighborhood expertise and process excellence. Generic five-star ratings with minimal text provide little training value compared to detailed testimonials that demonstrate concrete expertise.
Platform strategy: Focus where it matters
While the industry offers numerous specialized review platforms, market data reveals a clear hierarchy. According to BrightLocal’s 2025 consumer behavior survey, 83 percent of consumers check Google reviews, compared to just 44 percent who check other major platforms. This isn’t just about consumer preferences. It directly impacts the quality and quantity of AI training data.
Google’s dominance in search (with an 88 percent market share, according to DataPin’s research) means its review ecosystem provides the richest training environment for AI systems. Additionally, Google’s local search features capture up to 70 percent of local service interactions in home services industries, making Google Business Profile optimization critical for AI visibility.
Yelp emerges as the strategic secondary platform, ranking third in consumer usage according to BrightLocal data, following its recent integration of AI-powered review analysis tools. This integration means that Yelp reviews are increasingly contributing to AI system training data.
Strategic framework: Brokerage vs. agent approach
Successful implementation requires different strategies for brokerages and individual agents, though both should focus on the same core platforms.
Brokerages should establish market authority through comprehensive Google Business Profile optimization, targeting 100+ reviews minimum to establish credible sample sizes. The goal is to position the brokerage as the definitive market expert while maintaining consistent brand messaging across all agents.
Individual agents should build personal expertise authority through focused Google Business Profile development, targeting 50+ agent-specific reviews that demonstrate neighborhood knowledge and transaction expertise. This creates layered credibility: market authority at the brokerage level, specific expertise at the agent level.
Both approaches require systematic review collection, professional response protocols, and consistent Name, Address, Phone (NAP) formatting across all platforms to ensure AI systems can accurately identify and reference your business.
Implementation strategy
The transition to an AI-optimized review strategy should be a methodical process. Begin with Google Business Profile optimization, implementing systematic review collection processes that prioritize detailed, specific feedback over generic ratings. Establish Yelp presence as a secondary platform while maintaining any existing specialized platform investments strategically.
For established professionals with existing review platform investments, the key is integration rather than abandonment. Leverage existing content as templates for new review requests while gradually shifting focus toward platforms with proven AI integration. Ask vendors about their roadmap for AI optimization and how they plan to ensure your reviews contribute to AI training data, rather than remaining isolated from these emerging systems.
Response protocols matter significantly. According to ResponseScribe research, 88% of consumers prefer businesses that respond to every review, and these interactions provide additional context for AI training.
Looking forward
The real estate industry has always been relationship-driven, built on trust and local expertise. The AI revolution doesn’t change these fundamentals. It amplifies them. Agents and brokerages that have built genuine client satisfaction will find their authentic review patterns naturally align with what AI systems recognize as authority.
The opportunity lies in understanding this shift early. While competitors focus on traditional SEO tactics, forward-thinking professionals can build the review foundation that will drive AI recommendations for years to come.
Success in the AI era isn’t about gaming systems. It’s about being so consistently excellent that the systems naturally recognize your expertise. In real estate, that’s always been the path to sustainable success.
Molly McKinley is the founder of Redtail Creative and is the Entrepreneur-in-Residence and teaches entrepreneurship, innovation and social impact at Meredith College in Raleigh, North Carolina.
